C
originally loaned the money—an incentive to support the new federal government.
If the government failed, these creditors would never get their money back.
However, this proposal made many people in the South furious. Some Southern
states had already paid off most of their debts. Southerners resented assumption of
state debts because they thought that they would be taxed to help pay the debts
incurred by the Northern states.
PLAN FOR A NATIONAL BANK
Hamilton’s line of reasoning also motivated his
proposal for a national bank that would be funded by both the federal govern-
ment and wealthy private investors. Hamilton hoped to tie wealthy investors to
the country’s welfare. The Bank of the United States would issue paper
money and handle tax receipts and other government funds.
Hamilton’s proposals aroused a storm of controversy. Opponents of a
national bank, including James Madison, claimed that the bank would forge an
unhealthy alliance between the government and wealthy business interests.
Madison also argued that since the Constitution made no provision for
a national bank, Congress had no right to authorize it. This argument began
the debate between those who favored a “strict” interpretation of the
Constitution, one in which the federal government has very limited powers,
and a “loose” interpretation, which favors greater federal powers. The latter
group appealed to the so-called elastic clause of the Constitution (Article 1,
Section 8, Clause 18), which gives Congress the authority to do whatever is “nec-
essary and proper” to carry out its specific enumerated powers, such as regulating
commerce. In the end, however, Hamilton convinced Washington and a major-
ity in Congress to accept his views, and the federal government established the
Bank of the United States.
THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
To win support for his debt plan from
Southern states, Hamilton offered a suggestion: What if the nation’s capital
were moved from New York City to a new city in the South, on the banks of the
Potomac River? This idea pleased Southerners, particularly Virginians such as
Madison and Jefferson, who believed that a Southern site for the capital would
make the government more responsive to their interests. With this incentive,
Virginians agreed to back the debt plan. In 1790, the debt bill passed Congress,
along with authorization for the construction of a new national capital in the
District of Columbia, located between Maryland and Virginia.
Launching the New Nation 185
MAIN IDEA
MAIN IDEA
C
Analyzing
Issues
Why did the
new nation need
to pay off its
debts?
Contrasting Views of the Federal Government
HAMILTON
• Concentrating power in federal
government
• Fear of mob rule
• Republic led by a well-educated elite
• Loose interpretation of the Constitution
• National bank constitutional
(loose interpretation)
• Economy based on shipping
and manufacturing
• Payment of national and state debts
(favoring creditors)
• Supporters: merchants, manufacturers,
landowners, investors, lawyers, clergy
JEFFERSON
• Sharing power with state and local
governments; limited national government
• Fear of absolute power or ruler
• Democracy of virtuous farmers
and tradespeople
• Strict interpretation of the Constitution
• National bank unconstitutional
(strict interpretation)
• Economy based on farming
• Payment of only the national debt
(favoring debtors)
• Supporters: the “plain people”
(farmers, tradespeople)
SKILLBUILDER
Interpreting Charts
1.
Whose view of the federal government was a wealthy person more likely to favor? Why?
2.
How do you think Jefferson differed from Hamilton in his view of people and human nature?
C. Answer
Demonstrating
that the new
government was
financially
responsible
would make it
more credible
in the eyes of
creditors,
including foreign
governments,
and bolster the
government’s
reputation.