This information is intended as a procedural guide only.
You may wish to seek an attorney’s advice.
TIME TO RESPOND TO AN UNLAWFUL
DETAINER LAWSUIT
An unlawful detainer lawsuit is a “summary” court
procedure. This means that the court action moves
forward very quickly, and that the time given the
tenant to respond to the lawsuit is very short. In
most cases, the tenant has only five days,
including weekends, to file a written response to
the lawsuit after being served with a copy of the
Unlawful Detainer complaint. If the fifth day to
answer falls on a weekend or holiday, you can file
your answer on the following Monday or non-
holiday.
HOW TO RESPOND TO AN UNLAWFUL
DETAINER LAWSUIT
Typically, a tenant responds to a landlord’s
complaint by filing a legal document called an
Answer. If you are representing yourself in an
Unlawful Detainer action you are exempt from the
mandatory electronic filing rules (Code of Civil
Procedure, § 1010.6, Orange County Superior Court
Rule 352). You may file your response at the
address listed on the Summons and Complaint. If
you prefer, you may electronically file your
response. Filing information and service providers
can be found at www.occourts.org.
You must also
mail a copy of your answer to the plaintiff’s attorney
or if no attorney, to the plaintiff. Proof of Mailing
must be filed at the same time as the answer. Once
the answer has been filed either party may request
the case be set for trial by filing a “Request/Counter-
Request to Set Case for Trial – Unlawful Detainer”.
LEGAL DEFENSES
You may have a legal defense to the landlord’s
complaint. If so, you must state the defense in your
answer within the five-day period, or you will lose
any defenses that you may have. Some typical
defenses a tenant might have are:
•
The landlord’s three-day notice requested more
rent than was actually due.
•
The landlord did not maintain the property in
condition fit to live (i.e. the landlord breached the
implied warranty of habitability).
•
The landlord filed the eviction action against the
tenant for complaining about the condition of the
rental unit or for exercising a right the tenant has
under the law.
•
The landlord filed the eviction for an unlawful
discriminatory practice.
RETALIATORY ACTIONS AND EVICTIONS
A landlord may try to evict a tenant because the
tenant has complained about a problem in the rental
unit or exercised a legal right. The landlord cannot
retaliate against you because you called the Health
Department or any other government agency about
the condition of your home; you exercised your
rights to repair problems and deducted the cost from
your rent, you organized with other tenants or
formed an tenants’ association or you did anything
else you had a constitutional right to do such as
complaining to your landlord about the condition of
the rental unit.
BREACH OF THE WARRANTY OF
HABITABILITY
Under the law, the tenant does not have to pay full
rent if: there are serious problems that affect a
tenant’s health and safety; the landlord knew about
the problems; had time to fix them, but refused or
failed to do so; and the tenant(s) did not cause the
problem or refuse to allow repairs.
The law does not require the landlord to keep your
rental unit in perfect condition, but the landlord must
provide these basic services: plumbing that works,
hot and cold running water and enough hot water to
wash and bathe, heat, electricity and lights which
work and are safe, window screens, sufficient
extermination to keep out roaches, fleas, bugs and
mice or rats, clean common areas free from trash
and debris, safe and secure stairways and railings,
roofs, walls and windows that do not leak and are
not broken, and adequate security.
DISCRIMINATION
By trying to evict you, the landlord may be unlawfully
discriminating against you or your family. The law
provides that the landlord may not discriminate
against you or try to evict you simply because of
your race or ethnic group, your religion, national
origin or ancestry, your sex, your marital status, your
physical or mental handicap, or your sexual
orientation.
ADDITIONAL LEGAL RESPONSES
Depending on the facts of your case, there are other
legal responses to the landlord’s complaint that you
might file instead of an answer. For example:
If you believe that your landlord did not properly
serve the summons and the complaint, you
might file a Motion to Quash Service of
Summons.
If you believe that the complaint has some
technical defect or does not properly allege the
landlord’s right to evict you, you might file a
Demurrer.
Note: No forms are available for these types of responses. It
is important that you obtain advice from a lawyer before you
attempt to use these types of responses.
APPEARING IN COURT
Before appearing in court, you must carefully
prepare your case. Among other things you should:
Talk with a housing clinic; tenant organization;
attorney; or legal aid organization. This will help
you understand the legal issue in your case and
the evidence you will need.
Decide how you will present the facts that
support your side of the case, e.g., witnesses,
letters, other documents, photographs, video, or
other evidence.
Have at least four copies of all documents that
you intend to use as evidence: an original for the
judge, a copy for the opposing party, a copy for
yourself, and copies for your witnesses.
Ask witnesses to testify at trial if they will help
your case. You can subpoena a witness who
will not testify voluntarily. A subpoena is an
order from the court for a witness to appear.
The subpoena must be served (handed) to the
witness, and can be served by anyone who is
over the age of 18. You can obtain a subpoena
form from the Clerk’s Office. You must pay
witness fees at the time the subpoena is served
on the witness, if the witness requests them.