Grade
© 2008 Committee for Children www.secondstep.org
Page 199
Lesson 4
Academic Integration Activities
Language Arts and Social Studies
Can they respectfully disagree?
A town meeting is often used by local governments to obtain suggestions, get feedback on
existing policies and government officials, or debate potential policies and proposals.
Have students use the town meeting format to debate a proposal to build a new skateboard
park. Proponents of the proposal say that building a skateboard park will provide a
healthy outlet for our youth and keep them off busy streets. Opponents are worried
about the cost, the environmental impact, and the kinds of kids the park will attract. Put
students in small groups. Have half of the groups take the proponents’ perspective, and
the other half take the opponents’ perspective. In a town meeting format, have each group
present their arguments based on their perspective using the respectful disagreement skills
practiced in this lesson.
Health and Science
Is there life on other planets?
Have student groups contemplate the question: Is there life on other planets? Have half
of the groups take the position that there is life on other planets, and the other half that
there is not. Give the groups time to come up with support for their positions. Then
have opposing groups debate whether there is or is not life on other planets while using
respectful disagreement skills.
Media Literacy
Can you identify respectful disagreement skills?
Record a clip from an age-appropriate TV sitcom, drama, or movie that shows a conflict
between characters. Before showing the clip, direct your students to look for a conflict
between characters. Show the clip and have students analyze how the conflict is or is not
resolved. Do the characters use the skills for disagreeing respectfully? Have them write
down all the skills they see the characters using. If they are not using the skills, have them
describe how the conflict might have been resolved differently if they had. Then discuss
as a class or in groups some of the following questions: How often do you see respectful
disagreement on-screen? Do you think disrespect is seen as more compelling or exciting?
Why or why not? Do you think disrespectful or respectful disagreement between characters
on-screen is encouraged? Why?