(01/2003) USDOL/OALJ BLBA Evidence Summary
Page 5 of 7
IV. Medical reports
The parties are notified that “medical reports” may only be based on medical evidence which is admissible consistent with
the evidentiary limitations at 20 C.F.R. § 725.414(a)(2)(i), (3)(i), and (c) (2001). 20 C.F.R. §§ 725.414(a)(2)(i) and 725.457(d)
(2001). Medical reports are defined in the regulations as:
A physician’s written assessment of the miner’s respiratory or pulmonary condition. A medical report may
be prepared by the physician who examined the miner and/or reviewed the available admissible evidence.
A physician’s written assessment of a single objective test, such as a chest X-ray or a pulmonary function
test, shall not be considered a medical report for purposes of this section.
20 C.F.R. § 725.414(a)(1) (2001).
A. Initial evidence. A party may submit no more than two medical reports in support of its position. 20
C.F.R. § 725.414(a)(2)(i) and (3)(i) (2001).
Exhibit No. Physician
Date of
Medical Report Comments
OWCP Evaluation. The Department is required to provide the miner with a complete pulmonary evaluation.
20 C.F.R. § 725.406(a) (2001).
B. Rehabilitative evidence is permitted ONLY if opposing party has presented “rebuttal evidence” which
“tends to undermine” the conclusion of a physician who prepared one of the above-listed medical reports. It
is noted that “rebuttal evidence” may consist of “no more than one physician’s interpretation of each chest
X-ray, pulmonary function test, blood gas study, autopsy or biopsy” submitted by the opposing party. In
such a case, the proponent is entitled to submit an “additional statement” from the physician who prepared
the medical report explaining his or her conclusion in light of the rebuttal evidence. 20 C.F.R. §
725.414(a)(2)(ii) and (3)(ii) (2001).
Exhibit No. Physician
Date of
Report
Rehabilitation
of Exhibit No. Comments
For use by the Director only. The Director may submit rehabilitative evidence if any party submits
evidence which “tends to undermine” the findings of the Department-sponsored medical opinion.