Personnel
Board of Trustees Policy
SUBJECT:
Procedure for Resolving Complaints of
Discrimination, Harassment, and Retaliation
Numbe
r:
3.15
DATE:
November 19, 2018
SUPERSEDES:
Procedure for Resolving Complaints of
Discrimination, Harassment, and Retaliation
(Resolution #16-96)
This procedure document directly relates to the Procedure for Resolving
Complaints of Discrimination, Harassment, and Retaliation of the SUNY
Schenectady Board of Trustees, as hereto attached.
2
Discrimination and Harassment Policy and Complaint Resolution Procedure
for Students and Employees
Policy On Non-Discrimination and Harassment
In compliance with applicable federal, state and local laws, SUNY Schenectady County Community
College (the “College”) does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, gender, gender characteristics
and expression, sexual orientation, age, religion, actual or perceived national origin, actual or perceived
gender identity, marital status, military or veteran status, physical or mental disability, status as a victim
of a sexual assault, relationship violence, and/or stalking, genetic predisposition and carrier status,
previous convictions as specified by law, or any other characteristics protected by applicable law (the
“Protected Characteristics”), in any aspect of its admissions or financial aid programs, educational
programs and related activities, or with respect to employment and advancement in employment. The
College is committed to providing a work and learning environment that is free from discrimination
and harassment by anyone based on an individual’s Protected Characteristics, or because the individual
has engaged in activity protected by federal or state laws prohibiting discrimination.
Matters covered under these procedures in the employment relationship include, but are not limited
to, recruitment, hiring, job assignment, compensation, promotion, discipline, termination, and access
to benefits and training. Matters covered in the academic setting include, but are not limited to,
admission, housing, allocation of financial aid, use of college facilities, and the assignment of grades.
The Title IX Coordinator has been designated by the College to coordinate
its efforts to comply
with applicable nondiscrimination laws and regulations. Questions or concerns regarding the scope
and application of the College’s Discrimination and Harassment Policy and Complaint
Resolution Procedure for Students and Employees (the “Policy”) should be directed to the Interim
Title IX Coordinator Ms. Susan DiDonato, 518-381-1305.
In the absence of, or as an alternative to, the Title IX Coordinator, questions or concerns about this
Policy may also be addressed to:
Employees
Edmund J. McTernan
Executive Director of Human Resources
Elston Hall, Room 125
(518) 381-1331
mcternej@sunysccc.edu
Students
Sabrina McGinty
Assistant Vice President of Student Affairs
Elston Hall, Room 317
(518) 381-1378
mcgintse@sunysccc.edu
Susannah Adams, Coordinator of ADA Transition Services, is the individual designated by the College
to coordinate its efforts to comply with reasonable accommodation obligations towards qualified
3
individuals with disabilities. Questions or concerns regarding reasonable accommodation of
individuals with disabilities should be directed to Ms. Adams at Elston Hall, Room 222, (518) 381-
1345, adamssj@sunysccc.edu.
What Is Prohibited Harassment?
Prohibited harassment is a form of discrimination. In general, it can consist of spoken, written, and/or
electronically transmitted words, signs, jokes, pranks, intimidation, or physical violence based on the
protected characteristics of an employee or student, which alters the work or educational environment
of that employee or student. The most well-known type of prohibited harassment is sexual
harassment. Employee complaints of sexual harassment will be addressed pursuant to the College’s
Policy on Sexual Harassment of Employees, No. 2.14, (October 15, 2018) available at
http://sunysccc.edu/Portals/1/PDF/About%20SCCC/Policies%20and%20Procedures/Human%2
0Resources/2.14-SexualHarassmentOfEmployees.pdf?ver=2018-10-17-110732-720. Applicable laws
and/or this policy also prohibit harassment based on any of the Protected Characteristics. Student
complaints of sexual harassment and all (employee and student) complaints of harassment based on
any other Protected Characteristic will be addressed pursuant to this Policy.
In addition, retaliation resulting from an individual’s protected activity (i.e., opposition to prohibited
discrimination or participation in a statutory complaint process) is also prohibited. This prohibition
applies to anyone on the College campuses. Harassment of students who are working or studying
outside the campus proper is prohibited as well. The College is committed to preventing and
correcting all such harassment, not just harassment which is severe or pervasive enough to provide
the basis for a claim under federal or state law.
Sexual Harassment
The College is committed to maintaining a campus free from sexual harassment. Sexual harassment is
unlawful and may subject the College to liability. Any possible sexual harassment will be investigated
whenever the College receives a complaint or otherwise knows of possible sexual harassment
occurring. Those who engage in sexual harassment will be subject to disciplinary action. Supervisors
who fail to report sexual harassment will also be subject to disciplinary action.
Under federal and state law, sexual harassment includes unwelcome sexual advances, requests for
sexual favors, or other verbal or physical conduct of a sexual nature, when:
Such conduct is made either explicitly or implicitly a term or condition of employment or
enrollment,
Submission to or rejection of such conduct is used as the basis for employment or academic
decisions; or
Such conduct has the purpose or effect of unreasonably interfering with an individual’s work
or academic performance or creating an intimidating, hostile or offensive work or educational
environment, even if the complaining individual is not the intended target of the sexual
harassment.
4
However, this Policy prohibits all forms of sexual harassment, regardless of whether the harassment
may give rise to a legal claim. A single incident of inappropriate sexual behavior may be enough to rise
to the level of sexual harassment, depending on the severity of such incident.
Prohibited sexual harassment includes, but is not limited to the following:
Physical assaults of a sexual nature,
1
such as:
o Rape, sexual battery, molestation, or attempts to commit these assaults; and
o Intentional or unintentional physical conduct which is sexual in nature, such as
touching, pinching, patting, grabbing, brushing against another employee’s body, or
poking another employees’ body.
Unwanted sexual advances, propositions or other sexual comments, such as:
o Requests for sexual favors;
o Subtle or obvious pressure for unwelcome sexual activities;
o Sexually oriented gestures, noises, remarks, jokes or comments about a person’s
sexuality or sexual experience;
o Spoken, written, and/or electronically transmitted verbal remarks of a sexual nature
(whether directed to an individual or a group);
o Sexually explicit, offensive, or sex-based jokes and comments; and
o Sexual or gender-based comments about an individual or an individual’s appearance.
Sexual or discriminatory displays or publications anywhere in the workplace, such as:
o Displaying pictures, posters, calendars, graffiti, objects, promotional material, reading
materials, or other materials that are sexually demeaning, pornographic.
A type of sexual harassment known as “quid pro quo” harassment occurs when a person in authority
tries to trade job or academic benefits for sexual favors. This can include hiring, promotion, grading,
scheduling, continued enrollment or employment, or any other terms conditions or privileges of
enrollment or employment. To avoid the potential for quid pro quo sexual harassment, it is the policy
of the College that no sexual relationship should exist between supervisor (or evaluator) and
subordinate, including between student workers and their supervisors, or between faculty and
students, except as expressly permitted by the College’s Policy on Consensual Relationship, No. 2.28,
(August 20, 2018) available at
http://sunysccc.edu/Portals/1/PDF/
About%20SCCC/Policies%20and%20Procedures/Human%20Resources/2.28-
ConsensualRelationshipPolicy.pdf?ver=2018-08-23-160401-937 . If a prohibited sexual relationship
develops, the supervisory authority and/or responsibility for grading, evaluation, etc. should be
promptly transferred to another individual.
Sexual harassment is neither limited by the gender of either party, nor limited to supervisor-
subordinate or teacher-student relationships. Sexual harassment can occur between male and female
1
Any complaint of sexual assault, including rape or fondling, will be addressed pursuant to the
College’s Sexual Assault, Relationship Violence, and Stalking Policies for Students and Employees,
No. 3.16, (November 19, 2018) available at http://sunysccc.edu/Portals/1/PDF/About SCCC/Policies and
Procedures/Student/3.16-SexualAssault-RelationshipViolence-Stalking.pdf.
5
students and employees, or between persons of the same sex. Sexual harassment that occurs because
the victim is transgender is also unlawful.
Other Types of Harassment
Prohibited harassment on the basis of a Protected Characteristic, or any other protected basis, includes
behavior similar to sexual harassment, such as: (1) verbal, written, and/or electronically transmitted
conduct, including threats, epithets, derogatory comments, or slurs; (2) visual conduct, including
derogatory posters, photographs, cartoons, drawings, or gestures; and (3) physical conduct, including
assault, unwanted touching, or blocking normal movement. The College will not tolerate any such
harassment.
Prohibition of Retaliation
It is a violation of federal and state law and this policy for any employee or student to retaliate against
any student or employee for engaging in any protected activity under the Violence Against Women
Act, the Clery Act, Title VI, Title VII, Title IX, the New York State Human Rights Law, the ADA,
the Rehabilitation Act, the ADEA, and other federal and state civil rights laws.
Unlawful retaliation can be any action, more than trivial, that would have the effect of dissuading a
reasonable employee or student from making or supporting a charge of harassment or any other
practices forbidden by the Law. Actionable retaliation can occur after the individual is no longer
employed by, or enrolled at, the College. This can include, for example, giving an unwarranted negative
reference for a former employee or former student.
This includes retaliating against a student or employee who opposes a discriminatory practice, makes
a good faith complaint about harassment and/or discrimination, or furnishes information or
participates in any manner in an investigation of such a complaint.
Retaliation includes any conduct directed at someone because he or she engaged in such protected
activity, which might deter a reasonable student or employee from making or supporting a charge of
harassment or discrimination. Protected activity can include any of the following:
filing a complaint of discrimination or harassment, either internally with the College, or with
any anti-discrimination agency,
testifying or assisting in a proceeding or investigation involving discrimination or harassment,
opposing discrimination or harassment by making a verbal or informal complaint to
management, or by simply informing a supervisor or manager of discrimination or harassment,
complaining that another student or employee has been discriminated against or harassed,
encouraging another student or employee to report discrimination or harassment, and
requesting an accommodation for a disability or a religious practice.
Retaliation is unlawful and will not be tolerated. Any individual found to have engaged in retaliation
will be subject to disciplinary action, up to and including, termination of employment and/or dismissal
from the College.
6
Any employee or student who becomes aware of retaliation against a student or employee should
contact the Chief Diversity Office/Title IX Coordinator, the Executive Director of Human Resources
or the Assistant Vice President of Student Affairs.
Confidentiality
The College will, to the extent possible, maintain confidentiality with respect to complaints of
discrimination and prohibited harassment. However, there is no such thing as an “unofficial” or
“informal” complaint of discrimination or harassment. Once the College or its supervisors become
aware of a complaint, the College is required by law to take action consistent with this policy.
2
These
actions may require disclosure of the allegations to the extent necessary to conduct a complete and
thorough investigation.
Complaint, Investigation, and Disciplinary Procedure for Employees and Students
Reporting Prohibited Discrimination and Harassment
Any employee or student who believes he or she is the victim of prohibited discrimination or
harassment should file a complaint with the Chief Diversity Officer/Title IX Coordinator. If s/he is
not available, or if an employee or student does not feel comfortable reporting discrimination or
prohibited harassment to the Chief Diversity Officer/Title IX Coordinator, he or she may also report
it to any the Executive Director of Human Resources or the Assistant Vice President of Student
Affairs.
When an employee or student makes a report with the Chief Diversity Officer/Title IX Coordinator,
or designee, he or she will be given a written complaint form to complete. A sample copy of this form
is provided below. The Chief Diversity Officer/Title IX Coordinator or designee will also provide the
complainant and the respondent with copies of this Policy for review.
However, even if an employee or student chooses not to file a complaint with the College, if the
College knows, or reasonably should know, about a suspected incident of discrimination or
harassment, the College will promptly investigate to determine what occurred and then take
appropriate steps to resolve the situation.
All employees of the College are responsible for keeping the College’s working and learning
environment free from discrimination or prohibited harassment. For that reason, if an employee
observes or otherwise learns of conduct which may constitute discrimination or prohibited
harassment, the employee must report the conduct to the Chief Diversity Officer/Title IX
Coordinator, even if the employee is not the victim of that conduct.
In addition to filing a complaint with the College, an employee or student who believes he or she is
the victim of discrimination or harassment may file a complaint with the following federal, state or
local agencies:
2
College employees who learn of alleged discrimination or prohibited harassment as a result of
privileged communications with a student (e.g., through a counseling relationship) are exempted from
this requirement.
7
o United States Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights (“OCR”):
New York Office
Office for Civil Rights
U.S. Department of Education
32 Old Slip, 25th Floor
New York, NY 10005
Telephone: 646-428-3900
Fax: 646-428-3843
E-mail: ocr@ed.gov.
Online: https://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ocr/complaintintro.html
o United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (“EEOC”):
John E. Thompson Jr., Director
Buffalo Local Office
Olympic Towers
300 Pearl Street, Suite 450
Buffalo, NY 14202
Phone: 1-800-669-4000
Fax:
716-551-4387
Online: https://www.eeoc.gov/employees/howtofile.cfm
o New York State Division of Human Rights (“DHR”):
Victor DeAmelia, Regional Director
NYS Division of Human Rights
Agency Building 1, 2nd Floor, Empire State Plaza
Albany, New York 12220
Telephone: (518) 474-2705
Fax: (518) 473-2955
Email: InfoAlbany@dhr.ny.gov
Online: https://dhr.ny.gov/complaint
o Schenectady County Human Rights Commission
Executive Director
797 Broadway, Room 305
Schenectady, NY 12305
Telephone: (518) 377-2982
Fax: (518) 377-5374
Online: https://www.schenectadycounty.com/humanrights
Investigation of Complaints
When the College becomes aware that discrimination or prohibited harassment may exist, it is
obligated by law to take prompt and appropriate action. Failure to do so is considered a violation of
this Policy.
8
Once a complaint of discrimination or prohibited harassment has been made either in writing or orally,
or observed discrimination or harassment has been reported, the Title IX
Coordinator will make
an initial assessment regarding the validity of the complaint. Unless the
complaint is determined
to be invalid (e.g. erroneous information, failure to state a claim, mistaken identity, etc.), the Title
IX Coordinator, or designee (who must be trained in discrimination and harassment, and this
Policy), will promptly conduct a complete, thorough, and impartial investigation.
If the Title IX Coordinator or his or her adequately trained designee is
involved in the alleged
discrimination or harassment, the President will be responsible for choosing an adequately trained
designee to conduct the investigation. If it would be inappropriate for the Title IX Coordinator or
President to choose an adequately trained designee to conduct the investigation, then the Chair of
the Board of Trustees will make this designation.
While the investigation is being conducted, interim measures will be available to end or limit contact
between the complainant and the respondent. Interim measures may include:
support services (victim advocacy, housing assistance, academic support, counseling, health
and mental health services, legal assistance);
changing work assignments and situations (for employees);
changing course schedules, assignments, or test schedules (for students);
providing increased monitoring, supervision, or security; and
providing an escort.
No complainant is required to take advantage of these interim measures, but the College provides
them in an effort to offer help and support. Such interim measures can be requested by a complainant
or respondent, by contacting the Title IX Coordinator. The College will protect the
confidentiality of accommodations or protective measures provided to a complainant or
respondent, to the extent that doing so will not impair the College’s ability to provide the
accommodations or protective measures.
The standard of evidence used to evaluate a report of prohibited harassment or discrimination is a
“preponderance of the evidence.” Under this standard, a determination must be made on the basis of
whether it is more likely than not that the respondent student or employee violated this Policy.
In investigating the complaint, the Title IX Coordinator, or designee, shall:
1.
Meet with the appropriate individuals and review all appropriate records that bear on the case.
2.
Discuss the allegations in the complaint with the complainant and respondent at separate
meetings, and provide the complainant and respondent with equal opportunities to identify
witnesses and present evidence supporting their respective positions at these meetings.
3.
Provide the complainant and the respondent with the same opportunities for a non-attorney
support person or non-attorney advisor of their choice throughout the process, including any
meeting, conference, hearing or other procedural action.
9
4.
Attempt, where appropriate, to resolve the complaint by exploring and suggesting possible
alternative solutions to the problem with all involved parties, provided, however, that the
complainant will not be required to participate in mediation with the respondent.
5.
(If the preceding step does not resolve the problem), make and transmit a preponderance of
the evidence determination in the matter of the allegation of discrimination/harassment to the
complainant, respondent and, if the respondent is an employee, the employee’s supervisor (or
the President if the respondent is a senior officer), or, if the respondent is a student, the Vice
President of Academic and Student Affairs.
The time necessary to complete an investigation will vary depending upon the facts of a particular
case. In most cases, investigations will be completed no later than sixty (60) calendar days of receipt
of a complaint.
Following the Investigation
Once the investigation is complete, the parties will be informed, in writing, of the outcome, including
the finding, the sanctions (if any) and the rationale therefor. Delivery of this outcome will not be
delayed to either party, and should occur as nearly simultaneously as possible, without unnecessarily
bringing those in conflict into close proximity to each other.
All parties will be informed of their potential rights to exercise a request for appeal, where applicable,
under the Student Code of Conduct, Employee Handbook or contract, and/or applicable collective
bargaining agreement with the College. Should any change in outcome occur prior to finalization, all
parties will be timely informed in writing, and will be notified when the results of the resolution
process become final.
If the investigation reveals that discrimination and/or prohibited harassment did occur, the College
will take all appropriate remedial measures necessary to end such conduct, prevent any such future
conduct, and correct any personnel or academic decisions made which are related to the prohibited
conduct. Remedies may include, but are not limited to, continuing or commencing any of the above-
listed “interim measures.” These remedies are separate from, and in addition to, any interim measures
that may have been provided prior to the conclusion of the investigation. Such measures can be
requested by a complainant, by contacting the Executive Director of Human Resources (for
employees) or the Assistant Vice President of Student Affairs (for students).
Discipline
The College takes complaints of discrimination and prohibited harassment with the greatest
seriousness. For that reason, if, following the investigation, the Title IX
Coordinator or other
trained investigator concludes that it is more likely than not that the respondent
student or employee
violated this Policy, the College will pursue strong disciplinary action through its
own channels.
Internal disciplinary proceedings for cases of harassment and discrimination are fair and impartial,
include timely notice of meetings and timely and equal access to information and evidence that will be
used, and are conducted by unbiased decision makers who have no conflict of interest. The
10
proceedings are completed within a reasonably prompt, designated timeframe. Further information
regarding internal disciplinary proceedings for students can be found in the Student Code of Conduct.
Further information regarding internal disciplinary proceedings for employees can be found in the
Employee Handbook or contract and/or in any applicable collective bargaining agreement with the
College.
Following any internal disciplinary proceeding for cases of harassment and discrimination, the
complainant and respondent will be provided with simultaneous written notice of the result of the
proceeding, including any sanctions imposed that relate directly to the complainant, and the rationale
for the result and complainant -related sanctions.
Discipline for incidents of discrimination and harassment may take a variety of forms, depending upon
the circumstances of a particular case. Among the disciplinary sanctions which may be imposed on
students are the following: verbal warning, written reprimand, probation, restrictions, suspension and
expulsion. Among the disciplinary sanctions which may be imposed on employees are: verbal warning,
written reprimand, suspension without pay, and termination. The full range of student disciplinary
penalties is set forth in the Student Code of Conduct. Employee disciplinary penalties are set forth in
the Employee Handbook or contract and/or in any applicable collective bargaining agreement with
the College.
All parties will be simultaneously informed of their potential rights to exercise a request for an appeal
of the disciplinary determination, where applicable, under the Student Code of Conduct, Employee
Handbook or contract, and/or collective bargaining agreement with the College. Should any change
in outcome occur prior to finalization, all parties will be timely informed in writing, and will be notified
when the results of the resolution process become final.
Engaging in discrimination, prohibited harassment, or retaliation may also lead to civil and/or criminal
action under state or federal law. Any employee who, in violation of this Policy, engages in
discrimination, prohibited harassment or retaliation, is acting outside the scope of his or her
employment and may be personally liable for such actions and their consequences. In the event legal
proceedings are commenced against such an employee, the College may decline to provide legal,
financial or other assistance.
11
SUNY SCHENECTADY COUNTY COMMUNITY COLLEGE
DISCRIMINATION/HARASSMENT COMPLAINT
Name of Complainant: Date Filed:
(please print)
Home Address:
(Street)
(City) (State)
(Zip Code)
Home Telephone:
-
-
(Area
Code)
Signature:
Address:
(City) (State)
(Zip Code)
Email:
Telephone:
-
-
(Area
Code)
Position Held:
Basis for filing complaint of discrimination: Circle appropriate classification(s)
RACE ACTUAL OR PERCEIVED NATIONAL ORIGIN
COLOR MILITARY OR VETERAN STATUS
SEXUAL ORIENTATION GENDER CHARACTERISTICS AND EXPRESSION
MARITAL STATUS RELATIONSHIP VIOLENCE VICTIM
RETALIATION
PREVIOUS CONVICTION OR ARREST
DISABILITY
GENETIC PREDISPOSITION OR CARRIER
AGE VICTIM OF SEXUAL ASSAULT OR STALKING
RELIGION
ACTUAL OR PERCEIVED GENDER IDENTITY
GENDER
Date(s)/Time(s) alleged discrimination/harassing act occurred:
Place
of alleged discriminatory/harassing act:
12
Person(s) who committed alleged act(s) of discrimination/harassment:
Witnesses to the alleged discrimination/harassing act:
Description of Events Leading to Filing a Complaint:
Person assisting complainant (Optional):
Name: Title:
Organization:
Address:
(Street) (City) (State)
(Zip Code)
Telephone: -
- (Area Code)
Relief Sought by Complainant: