AOA Form No. 145 Rev. 01/13) - Copyright 2006 - Apartment Owners Association of California, Inc. - www.aoausa.com
▪ San Fernando Valley (818)988-9200 ▪ Los Angeles (323)937-8811 ▪ Long Beach (562)597-2422 ▪ Garden Grove (714)539-6000 ▪ San Diego (619)280-7007 ▪ Northern California (510)769-7521
This chapter outlines the proper steps to take to deal with property left behind by tenants who have moved out,
so that you can prepare the premises for the next tenant. Obviously, you want to protect yourself from claims by
the tenant who has moved out that you have destroyed or stolen her property. (In legal jargon, this is known as
“unlawful conversion.” Conversion occurs when you take someone else’s property and convert it to your own use
or benefit, either by selling it or otherwise disposing of it, or using it yourself.)
A. PERSONAL PROPERTY
Whether a tenant vacates voluntarily, or with the aid of the sheriff or marshal, landlords all too often must not
only clean up and repair damage, but also dispose of a pile of junk. You’re much more likely to deal with a
tenant’s property when the tenant was evicted and wasn’t allowed to take everything. The belongings of evicted
tenants are not put into the street. The law enforcement officer performing an eviction will allow the tenant to
carry out a few armloads of personal possessions, leaving the remainder to be locked in the premises and stored
by you until the tenant can arrange to take them away.
Removing obvious trash is normally no problem, but even here you must exercise care. If you toss a moth-eaten
book in the dumpster, and it turns out to have been a valuable first edition, you could have problems.
As a general rule, the more valuable the property left behind by a tenant, the more formalities you must comply
with when disposing of it. In rare instances, you may have a judgment against a tenant for unpaid rent or
damages to your premises, and this tenant has left behind valuable property that she never claims. If so, you
can safely have the property sold and the money applied to pay your judgment, but only if you follow the legal
procedures outlined in this chapter.
You cannot touch a tenant’s property until you have legally gained possession of the premises. This occurs when
a tenant finally leaves voluntarily, whether or not she gives you the keys, or when the tenant is physically
evicted by the sheriff, marshal or constable. If you gained possession of the property after having heard nothing
from the tenant for 18 days since mailing a Notice of Belief of Abandonment (see Chapter 19), you should
understand that your mailing of the abandonment notice relating to the real property---the premises---has
nothing to do with any personal property abandoned inside. In other words, it only allows you to enter legally
after the premises we abandoned, not dispose of property. You may dispose of property only after following the
procedures described in this chapter.
1. If the Tenant Demands His Property
Ideally, a tenant who has left behind property after moving out will contact you about reclaiming it. If not, try to
contact the tenant to pick up the property. If you can’t reach him, look through the tenant’s rental application
and phone personal or business references listed there.
By all means, if a tenant is willing to pick up his property, return everything to him, even if he owes you money.
If a tenant owes you money---for example, back rent---you cannot insist that he pay you before you return his
property. You can, however, deduct back rent from any security deposit. But remember that the basic rule for
returning deposits within three weeks after the tenant leaves applies to abandonments---regardless of whether
the tenant has left property behind. (See Chapter 20 for details on returning security deposits.)
There’s one exception, however: You may insist the tenant pay your costs of moving and storing the
property before you return his belongings. If you’ve kept the property on the premises the tenant vacated, you
have the right to insist on being paid the prorated daily rental value for keeping the property on your premises
and/or any out-of-pocket costs you incur after that for renting storage space. You can also subtract the value of
your time for packing the tenant’s property up in the first place.
However, in most situations where there is not a lot of property, we recommend that you give the tenant his
belongings and forget about any charges, particularly if you didn’t incur any out-of-pocket expenses. It’s just not
worth it to get in fights over $75 worth of used books, records and old clothes. If you insist on too high a storage
charge, and the tenant refuses to pay it, you will end up having to keep or sell the tenant’s property. As a result,
the tenant may sue you, raising the possibility that a judge may hold you liable for the entire value of the
property because your storage charge wasn’t reasonable in the first place. Under state law (CC § 1965), a
landlord who fails to promptly return a tenant’s belongings may be liable for the value of the property plus $250
and the tenant’s attorney fees.
The process by which a tenant demands his pr
operty is supposed to work this
way:
The tenant moves out, leaving personal belongings behind.
Within 18 days, the tenant writes the landlord demanding the return of his property.