LAYPERSON'S GUIDE TO
California Wastewater
Prepared by the Water Education Foundation
WATER EDUCATION
FOUNDATION
717 K Street, Suite 317
Sacramento, CA 95814
916.444.6240
www.watereducation.org
www.aquafornia.com
The
Layperson's Guide to California Wastewater
is prepared
and distributed by the Water Education Foundation as a
public information tool.lt is part of a series of Layperson's
Guides that explore pertinent water issues in an objective,
easy-to-understand manner.
The mission of the Water Education Foundation, an
impartial, nonprofit organization, is to create a better
understanding of water resources and foster public
understanding and resolution of water resource issues
through facilitation, education and outreach.
For more information contact:
144
1/4
/
,
WATER EDUCATION
FOUNDATION
717 K Street, Suite 317
Sacramento, CA 95814
Phone: (916) 444-6240
Fax: (916) 448-7699
www.watereducation.org
www.aquafornia.com
President:William R.Mills
Executive Director:Rita Schmidt Sudman
Editor:Sue McClurg
Author:Cindy Nickles
Editorial Assistance:Robin Douglas
Design:Curtis Leipold
Photo Credits:
Leslie Scopes Anderson
California Association of Sanitation Agencies
Coachella Valley Water District
City of Los Angeles, Department of Public Works
Lara Meeker with Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Orange County Sanitation District
Sacramento Regional County Sanitation District
Sacramento Suburban Water District
San Francisco Public Library
Graphics:
Sacramento Regional County Sanitation District
Introduction
Background
Legal and Regulatory Primer
Collection and Conveyance
Treatment and Disposal
Current Challenges
Case Studies
E
The Future
Printed 2013
ISBN: 978-1 -61 948-002-5
© Copyright Water Education Foundation
On the Cover:
The secondary clarifier at the Western Water Recycling Facility.
Photo by Western Municipal Water District, Michael J. Elderman Photography
Digesters at a wastewater
treatment plant destroy
pathogens, resulting in
biosolids that may be
recycled.
Today's Wastewater Systems
Does anyone really ever give a second thought about
what happens to the water used after toilet flushing,teeth
brushing, showering, doing laundry and washing dishes?
Usually out of sight, out of mind are the thoughts of
private citizens of the day-to-day inspection, preventive
maintenance and operation of sewer systems; repair and
replacement of aging sewer pipes and other infrastruc-
ture; collection of sewage and treatment of wastewater;
and sewage disposal and pollution prevention.
California has many different types of entities that
collect, convey, treat and dispose of their community's
wastewater. Under the special district classification,there
are sanitary districts, sanitation districts, water districts
and community services districts. Cities, counties and
joint powers authorities can also be wastewater service
providers.
To sum up their tasks, these entities are responsible for
almost all wastewater infrastructure planning, funding,
design and construction activities along with mainte-
nance and operation of the facilities for their ratepayers.
In general, they operate their own budgets with money
collected from property taxes and ratepayer fees and
spent within local service areas.
There are basic organizational differences among the
entities, however. For example, sanitary districts like the
Rancho Murieta Community Services District and Goleta
Sanitary District have elected boards, while the boards
of directors for sanitation districts like the Sacramento
Regional County Sanitation District and Sonoma County
Water Agency are comprised of members from county
boards of supervisors and city councils.
Agencies also differ in that some encompass both waste-
water collection and treatment services, while others
divide the duties. In the Bay Area, the Central Contra
Costa Sanitary District is responsible for both collecting
and treating wastewater. Coachella Valley Water District
provides wastewater collection and treatment services
in Riverside County and small portions of Imperial and
San Diego counties.ln Lake County,the city of Clear Lake
maintains the sewer lines within city limits,and the Clear
Lake Sanitary District is responsible for the treatment of
the sewage at the district treatment plant.
Public agency personnel and equipment are available
around the clock 24 hours a day, seven days a week, 365
days a year to respond to residential, commercial and
industrial customer emergencies, including sewage
backups, overflows and loss of service.
In general,agencies that provide wastewater services are
public - not private. Their public origins can be traced
back to the leadership of Governor Hiram Johnson and
his push for public programs and social reforms against
a backdrop of private political corruption."With public
servants whose sole thought is the good of the state the
prosperity of the state is assured, exaction and extortion
from the people will be at an end, in every material aspect
advancement will be ours, development and progress
will follow as a matter of course, and popular govern-
ment will be perpetuated," he said in his first inaugural
address on Jan. 3, 1911.
The importance of these public agency services in the
daily lives of residents and business owners is the take-
home message in a city of Los Angeles Department of
Public Works video, "A Day Without Public Works." The
video available at www.youtube.com
also delivers the
message that support for infrastructure spending is
critical to accommodate upgrading and maintenance
of aging public works, including wastewater systems.
Today's wastewater agencies are also focused on water
reuse, byproducts recycling and renewable energy pro-
duction. Many are engaged in full scale water recycling
efforts designed to provide new sources of water supply
for Californians, while others are involved in producing
renewable energy such as digester gas that can be used
on-site or fed back into the electrical system to provide
green energy for others.
Glossary
Biosolids
-
The solid organic material that is separated during the wastewater treatment process, treated
according to regulations to the point that it is a usable product, and then recycled.
Clarify
-
To make clear or pure by separating and eliminating suspended solid material.
Coagulation
-
The
clumping together of solids so they can more easily be settled out or filtered out of water.
Collection System
-
The sewer system of pipes that carries wastewater from homes and businesses to a
treatment plant or reclamation plant.
Combined Sewer
-
A wastewater collection system that carries both raw sewage and stormwater to a
treatment plant.
Disinfection
-
Final step in the treatment process. Commonly, chlorine is added to the treated wastewater
to kill disease-causing organisms. There are other alternatives for achieving disinfection, including
ultraviolet light.
Effluent
-
Treated wastewater flowing out of a treatment plant.
Filtration
-
The process of water passing through porous material such as sand or synthetic membranes to
trap and remove particles.
Influent - Untreated wastewater that enters a wastewater treatment plant.
Prima ry Treatment
-
First major treatment in a wastewater treatment facility that removes solids and floating
matter using screening, skimming and sedimentation.
Publicly Owned Treatment Works (POTWs)
-
Public wastewater systems built,operated and maintained by
government agencies.They include sewer pipes, maintenance holes (formerly called manholes), pumps,
treatment plants and other related infrastructure.
Reverse Osmosis
-
A method of removing very small particles, including salts or other ions, from water by
forcing water through a semi-permeable membrane.
Secondary Treatment
-
The biological portion of wastewater treatment that relies on the growth of micro-
organisms to clean the wastewater after primary treatment.Several different types of secondary processes
can be used, including activated sludge, trickling filters, pond systems and wetland systems.
Sedimentation
-
The settling of solids in a body of water using gravity.
Sludge
-
The organic solid waste material that settles out in the wastewater treatment process. If sludge is
converted into a usable end product, it is no longer called sludge.
TertiaryTreatment
-
Additional treatment processes used to clean wastewater even further following primary
and secondary treatment. Normally implies the removal of nutrients, such as phosphorous and nitrogen,
and a high percentage of suspended solids. Also known as advanced treatment.
Wastewater
-
The mixture of used water and human waste carried away by drains and sewers.
Water Recycling
-
The treatment of wastewater to make it suitable for a beneficial reuse, such as landscape
irrigation or groundwater recharge. A separate
Layperson's Guide to Water Recycling
has been published
by the Water Education Foundation and is available at
www.watereducation.orq
7
6
Le
al and Re
ulator Primer
Biological processes
are incorporated during
secondary treatment to
remove contaminants
dissolved in the wastewater.
_
"No one shall with malice pollute the waters where they
issue publicly.Should anyone pollute them, his fine shall
be ten thousand sestertii." - Sextus Juliano Frontinus,
Water Commissioner of the city of Rome, 97 AD (Source:
www.sewerhistory.oro)
Laws and regulations against water pollution have been
in existence for ages in one form or another with varying
degrees of effectiveness.
On the legislative front in the 1940s, both state and
federal governments began to seriously address the
increasing water quality problems resulting from unprec-
edented population growth and industrial development.
In California, problems with the assortment of water pol-
lution laws on the books ranged from overlapping regula-
tions and dueling government agencies to differing legal
interpretations.Among those advocating for action were
urban, industrial,agricultural and recreational water users.
As a result, the Legislature enacted the Dickey Water
Pollution Act (Dickey Act), which took effect Oct.1,1949.
Under the Dickey Act, a State Water Pollution Control
Board was created to set statewide policy and coordinate
state agency activities in controlling water pollution.
It also created nine Regional Water Pollution Control
Boards for each of the state's major watersheds to deal
with region-specific issues, depending on geography
-7
7
a
_AL
0
,
141
ir$
4.1
,
rn
a7c
SI
-
4
-
• -!
Imall
111111M
L
IAL
!.-1!
and precipitation,along with the needs of region-specific
recreation, agriculture and industry.
In 1948 Congress passed the Federal Water Pollution
Control Act, which over the years was often amended,
sometimes extensively.
Into the 1950s and 1960s, revisions were made to both
federal and state water pollution laws. In California, for
example,theWater Pollution Control Board was renamed
the State Water Quality Control Board to emphasize a
broader field of water quality issues than sewage and in-
dustrial waste control responsibilities.A follow-up change
toward a more coordinated water regulatory program
resulted in the merger of the State Water Quality Control
Board and State Water Rights Board into the State Water
Resources Control Board (State Water Board) in 1967.
In 1969 the Legislature enacted the centerpiece of
California's water quality legislation - the Porter-Cologne
Water Quality Control Act (Porter-Cologne Act).
In part, Section 13000 of the law says that"activities and
factors which may affect the quality of the waters of the
state shall be regulated to attain the highest water quality
which is reasonable,considering all demands being made
and to be made on those waters and the total values
involved, beneficial and detrimental,economic and social,
tangible and intangible."
iiii$11111
nii
""
nr!
• ... ! . , ..•.w.jopy clot
iflfl
ral
4
7
M.A.
2
=4
1
:
,
.
_
:an
to SI
Wills
Er
irlli
urn ism sr
LT.
rry-r
The Porter-Cologne Act authorized the StateWater Board
to develop statewide policy for water quality control. In
an excerpt,the law said,"The health,safety and welfare of
the people of the state requires that there be a statewide
program for the control of the quality of all the waters
of the state."
Also, it expanded the authority of the nine Regional Water
Quality Control Boards (Regional Water Boards), which
were the former Regional Water Pollution Control Boards.
As the Porter-Cologne Act said,"Factors of precipitation,
topography, population, recreation, agriculture, industry
and economic development vary from region to region
within the state;and that the statewide program for water
quality control can be most effectively administered
regionally, within a framework of statewide coordina-
tion and policy."
Based on watersheds, the Regional Water Boards are
referred to by specific names:North Coast,San Francisco
Bay, Central Coast, Los Angeles, Central Valley, Lahontan,
Colorado River Basin, Santa Ana and San Diego. Under
their new authority,they were to establish region-specific
water quality standards and adopt water quality control
plans, issue permits for the discharge of treated waste-
water that specified maximum-allowed levels of pollut-
ants, monitor discharges and manage polluted runoff.
Together the State Water Board and Regional Water
Boards are referred to as the California Water Boards
and are included under the umbrella of the California
Environmental Protection Agency (Cal/EPA) headquar-
tered in Sacramento.
Meantime back on Capitol Hill, environmental-related
activities had become a national priority following the
establishment of the U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA) in 1970. The public, Congress and the
president rallied behind a consistent, comprehensive,
long-term approach to water pollution control.
President Richard Nixon's State of the Union address Jan.
22,1970, included the following excerpt:"Clean air, clean
water, open spaces - these should once again be the
birthright of every American. ... I shall propose to this
Congress a $10 billion nationwide clean waters program
to put modern municipal waste treatment plants in every
place in America where they are needed to make our
waters clean again, and do it now."
Congress passed the Federal Water Pollution Control
Act Amendments of 1972 (Public Law 92-500), referred
to as the Clean Water Act, and now the main federal law
on water pollution in the United States. So influential
was California's Porter-Cologne Act that sections of it
were used as the basis to write the CWA. A federal-state
partnership, its goal was to "restore and maintain the
chemical, physical and biological integrity of the nation's
waters."
Under the authority of EPA, the new law required
standards for surface water quality, mandated sewage
treatment and regulated wastewater discharges into the
nation's surface waters. It would set water quality goals,
guidelines and technology based limits, but individual
states, territories and tribes would primarily administer
and enforce the federal programs on their own, includ-
ing the development of water quality standards. The
CWA also set the stage for state and federal government
entities to provide significant technical and financial
assistance to the regulated community.
During the early stages of the CWA implementation, the
focus was on designing, building and operating waste-
water treatment systems for pollution control. Federal
and state funding programs, including California bond
measures passed by voters, helped communities finance
municipal wastewater collection and treatment facilities.
For California to operate under the CWA, the state's
Porter-Cologne Act was amended to authorize the State
Water Board and Regional Water Boards to implement
the federal programs (see page 10).
All aspects of the
wastewater treatment
process are featured on
a school education "job
shadowing" tour for high
school students and a
teacher.
9
In 1972 Congress passed
the Clean Water Act.
Discharge Permit Program
The CWA made it against the law to discharge pollutants
from what are called"point sources"(including discharges
from wastewater treatment plant pipes, ditches or other
conveyances)"into the waters of the United States"unless
authorized by a permit under a program called the
National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES).
California law requires wastewater treatment plants to
have permits if they discharge treated wastewater to land.
Each and every publicly owned wastewater treatment
plant in California must have an individualized permit
issued by its Regional Water Board to comply with a
very detailed and complex set of operating conditions
to discharge treated wastewater. In the 1970s permits
were 10- to 20-page documents. Today some permits
can exceed 200 pages, but they average between 150
and 175 pages.
Permits have many requirements. They set maximum
limits on concentrations and mass emissions of pollutants
in treated wastewater before it can be discharged, along
with monitoring and reporting requirements. A permit
will also specify if additional actions are required such as
industrial pretreatment or sewer overflow programs. By
law, the specific methods undertaken in order to meet
specifications in the permit are at the discretion of the
wastewater agency.
Permitting is not a one-size-fits-all process. No two
discharge permits are identical because each permit
is customized for the type of water body the treated
wastewater is released into (whether a lake or stream,
for example) and the uses of that water body (whether
for swimming or drinking,for example).Similar to driver's
license renewals, permits must also be renewed at regular
intervals and under certain conditions can also be denied.
Permits can be re-opened prior to expiration depending
on the circumstances.
Treated wastewater discharged by treatment plants
must meet limits that are set for wastewater contami-
nants, called constituents, by the Regional Water Boards.
Constituents vary widely, but the major classes are nutri-
ents, microorganisms,salts, metals, natural organic matter
and synthetic organic compounds. Limitations involving
concentration (in parts per million or milligrams per liter)
and/or mass (pounds per day or grams per day) are used
for measuring and controlling pollutants.
Twenty first century scientific and technological advance-
ments are making it possible to detect minute levels of
compounds in the environment.Wastewater profession-
als, scientists, regulators and others are monitoring these
contaminants, referred to as "emerging constituents."
(See Challenges chapter.)
As part of the law, Congress established the National
Pretreatment Program to remove industrial pollutants
such as copper, lead, nickel, other heavy metals and
organic compounds before they reach the public waste-
water system.The practice is called "pretreatment."
Pretreatment programs, which are included in discharge
permits issued to all but the smallest wastewater
treatment agencies, require industries to remove their
own contaminants before their wastewater enters
into the sewer system where it can cause damage to
sewer collection systems, interference with wastewater
treatment plant operations and contamination of sewage
sludge.
For example, since 1973 Goleta Sanitary District in
Santa Barbara County has been operating a pretreatment
program. Under its Industrial Waste Control Program,
industrial and commercial customers are required to
keep hazardous substances out of the sewer collection
system. The goals of this program are to protect ocean
water quality and the district's treatment plant.
Regional Water Boards monitor wastewater treatment
plants for compliance with their permits, including inspec-
tions and reviews of water quality reports.Noncompliance
can result in heavy fines ranging upward of $1 million. A
Cease and Desist Order may also be issued to a wastewater
treatment plant for a violation or threatened violation of
a waste discharge requirement and permit. Depending
on the circumstance,the order could require the plant to
comply immediately, include a schedule for compliance
or take a preventive action.
Regional Board Requirements
Under the law, each Regional Water Board must develop
and adopt a long-range Basin Plan, also called a Water
Quality Control Plan. Basin Plans are required to include
water quality objectives, policies, regulations and
implementation programs along with the designated
"beneficial uses" of the water bodies within the regions
such as drinking, swimming,fishing,protection of aquatic
life and agricultural irrigation. The law calls for them to
be reviewed on a three-year cycle for updating with new
science, water quality issues and laws and regulations.
The Regional Water Boards must also make lists of water
bodies and constituents in each water body that are not
meeting water quality standards as set in their Basin
Plans. These lists are called 303(d) lists after the section
in the CWA.
California's 2008-10 303(d) list, the most recent available,
numbered 1,133 water body segments for all nine Regional
Water Boards and included rankings of high, medium or
low priorities. It is revised in even-numbered years.
For each lake, river, bay,ocean area or other body of water
on the 303(d) list, the Regional Water Board prepares a
written restoration plan, similar to a pollution budget for
the water body. The plan, called a Total Maximum Daily
Load (TMDL), includes all sources of pollutants, explains
how the particular water body doesn't measure up to the
water quality standards set for it,offers an action plan for
how it will improve water quality and develops a schedule
for actions.The TMDLs, or written reports, must account
for all sources of the pollutants that caused the water to
be listed. Complex TMDLs can cost more than $1 million
to prepare and significantly more to implement.
The Lake Tahoe TMDL, a Nevada and California bi-state
plan, was approved by EPA in 2011 after 10 years of
scientific studies.To reach the goal of returning the lake
to almost 100 feet of clarity within 65 years, the report
requires reductions in sediments and nutrients to be
achieved in each of the four primary sources of these
pollutants:urban stormwater runoff,forest runoff, stream
channel erosion and atmospheric deposition.TheTMDL
outlines measures to reduce each source.To reduce the
amount of fine sediment and nutrients entering the
lake, the California Lahontan Regional Water Board and
the Nevada Division of Environmental Protection will
coordinate with local jurisdictions, including the counties,
departments of transportation, the city of South Lake
Tahoe and other stakeholders.
To address and regulate water quality pollution problems
that cross regional boundaries or are statewide,the State
Water Board may also develop what are called Water
Quality Control Plans, and has adopted plans to address
enclosed bays and estuaries, ocean waters, temperature
(thermal), and the San Francisco Bay/Sacramento-San
Joaquin Delta Estuary.
Secondary clarifiers
separate the solids froni
the liquids during the
wastewater treatment
process.
11
Because of mercury pollution issues in the San Francisco
Bay, the San Francisco Bay Regional Water Board set a
Mercury TMDL and issued a watershed permit that must
be followed by public wastewater treatment plants,
generally referred to as publicly owned treatment works
or POTWs, and others in the Bay Area. To help comply
with the TMDL,the Bay Area Pollution Prevention Group
has initiated outreach programs to dental assistants and
hygienist schools to remind them to practice mercury
best management practices.
The federal and state water quality laws are dynamic
laws that continue to be amended to reflect new
issues, including recent changes addressing biosolids
management.
The public has many opportunities to participate in State
Water Board and Regional Water Board activities — from
formal hearings to informal collaborative stakeholder
sessions. People may also sign up for mailing and e-mail
lists, watch webcasts and webinars, and access online
databases. (See References sidebar.)
Wastewater agencies are also regulated by other
government agencies (see sidebar) and may fall under
the jurisdiction of other laws, including the California
Environmental Quality Act and federal Clean Air Act. An
example would be the air pollution laws in Southern
California's South Coast Air Basin that trigger local waste-
water agencies to follow regulations for combustion
devices and emergency engines.
Primary Agencies Involved in Wastewater
California State Water Resources Control Board -
Created by the Legislature in 1967,the five full-time mem-
ber State Water Board protects water quality by setting statewide policy, coordinating and supporting the
Regional Water Board efforts and reviewing petitions that contest Regional Water Board actions.The State
Water Board is also solely responsible for allocating surface water rights. The members are appointed to
four-year terms by the governor and confirmed by the Senate.
http://www.swrcb.ca.gov
Regional Water Quality Control Boards -There
are nine Regional Water Boards, each with seven part-time
members appointed by the governor and confirmed by the Senate. They develop basin plans for their
hydrologic areas, govern requirements/issue waste discharge permits, take enforcement action against
violators and monitor water quality.
http://www.waterboards.ca.gov/waterboards
map.shtml
Region 1 -
North Coastal Regional Water Quality Control Board
Region 2 -
San Francisco Bay Regional Water Quality Control Board
Region 3 -
Central Coastal Regional Water Quality Control Board
Region 4 -
Los Angeles Regional Water Quality Control Board
Region 5 -
Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board
Region 6 -
Lahontan Regional Water Quality Control Board
Region 7 -
Colorado River Regional Water Quality Control Board
Region 8 -
Santa Ana Regional Water Quality Control Board
Region 9 -
San Diego Regional Water Quality Control Board
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) -
Established in 1970, EPA is a federal regulatory agency
responsible for protecting environmental quality throughout the nation. It acts in an oversight role over
the State and Regional Water Boards and their implementation of the Clean Water Act (CWA). EPA's Office
of Wastewater Management, under the CWA, works with EPA regions, states, local governments, tribes,
the private sector and non-governmental organizations to regulate discharges into surface waters such
as wetlands, lakes, rivers, estuaries, bays and oceans. California is under the jurisdiction of EPA Region 9
(Pacific Southwest).
California Air Resources Board -
http://www.arb.ca.gov
California Department of Fish and Wildlife -
http://www.dfg.ca.gov
California Department of Pesticide Regulation -
http://www.cdpr.ca.gov
California Department of Public Health -
http://www.cdph.ca.gov
Collection and Conve ance
Although wastewater collection systems are mostly
invisible, the public can rest assured that vast labyrinths
of pipelines are beneath their feet collecting and moving
raw sewage away from homes, schools, restaurants,
shops and other businesses and into the principal sewer
mains also buried deep under streets, alleys or other
rights-of-way.
Local wastewater agencies own and are typically respon-
sible for the entire wastewater collection and conveyance
infrastructure. One possible exception is sewer laterals
that extend from the residence or building to the sewer
main line that is shared with others. Sewer laterals can
be owned by the wastewater agency or by the private
property owners.
Sewer mains connect to collectors and trunk lines, all
increasingly larger pipes that may eventually become
interceptor pipes — some interceptor pipes are 10 feet
or larger in diameter.These pipes convey wastewater to
treatment plants. Like tunnels, the larger pipes can be
walked through for maintenance, repairs and inspec-
tions. Most everyone has seen the metal plates that
cover maintenance holes (formerly called manholes) that
provide access to the sewers.
Because of California's diverse geography, a number
of system configurations are used. Gravity, pumping
plants or a combination of both conveys wastewater
to treatment plants. In a low-lying area such as a beach
community or a mountainous location, pumping plants
or lift stations are necessary to move wastewater under
pressure to higher elevations. Pressurized pipes coming
out of pumping plants are called force main sewers, or
force mains. Drop structures move wastewater from
higher to lower elevations, and siphons move it under-
neath freeways and rivers.
In Contra Costa County, for example, about 45 million
gallons of wastewater from more than 461,000
residential and more than 5,000 business customers
flow each day primarily by gravity through more than
1,500 miles of underground pipe in Central Contra
Costa Sanitary District's collection system to its Martinez
Treatment Plant.
Los Angeles has one of the largest collection systems
in the world, including more than 6,700 miles of public
sewers serving a population of more than 4 million. Its
wastewater collection system, which contains 140,000
maintenance holes, conveys about 400 million gallons
per day of flow from residences and businesses.
South Tahoe Public Utility District's collection system
includes 330 miles of sewer lines, 42 lift stations and
17,000 connections.
As raw sewage travels from Point A to Point B, there is
the risk of wastewater overflows (sewer spills) caused by
clogged pipes, tree roots that block pipes, deteriorating
and aging pipes, and heavy rain storms that overwhelm
the system with too much water.
To keep sewers working, agencies focus on a wide variety
of operations and maintenance activities. Crews of
maintenance workers inspect sewer systems manually
and by closed-circuit television,clean the insides of pipes,
remove roots,construct new sewer pipes or repair aging
ones and provide emergency response for overflows
and backups.
This sewer project consists
of approximately 34,300
lineal feet of 33-inch and
42-inch diameter gravity
sewer pipeline.
12
13
Resources
Bay Area Clean Water Agencies -
A local government agency created by a joint powers agreement in 1984.
Its membership includes wastewater agencies that provide sanitary sewer services to more than 7 million
people living in the nine-county San Francisco Bay Area. Principal members include the Central Costa
County Sanitation District,the city of San Jose, East Bay Dischargers Association, East Bay Municipal Utility
District and San Francisco Public Utilities District.
http://bacwa.orq
alifornia Association of Sanitation Agencies -
A statewide trade association of municipalities, special
districts and joint powers agencies that provide wastewater collection, treatment and water recycling
services. CASA was founded in 1955 and CASA members represent more than 90 percent of the sewered
population of California.
www.casaweb.orq
Central
Rural Water Association -
Provides on-site technical assistance and specialized training for rural
water and wastewater systems.
http://www.calruralwater.orq
Central Valley Clean Water Association -
A regional association representing wastewater treatment and
collection system agencies in the Central Valley.
http://www.cvcwa.orq
California Water Environment Association -
A statewide nonprofit public benefit association whose mission
is to protect the water environment by educating, training and certifying the competency of individuals
who work in the water quality field. Approximately 80 percent of CWEA's more than 9,000 members work
for municipal wastewater agencies and collection systems, both large and small, throughout California.
www.cwea.orq
Southern California Alliance of Publicly Owned Treatment Works -
A nonprofit corporation of more
than 90 wastewater treatment and collection system agencies
and one large regional water treatment
agency.Together, its membership collects and/or treats the wastewater for more than 16 million Southern
Californians in seven counties.
www.scapl.org
My Water Quality Website -
Sponsored by the California Water Quality Monitoring Council, a joint partner-
ship between the California Environmental Protection Agency, the California Natural Resources Agency,
and several stakeholder organizations from both inside and outside state government. State legislation
in 2006 mandated water quality monitoring and assessment activities be coordinated and information
be made available to decision makers and the public via the Internet.
http://www.CaWaterOuality.net
Treatment and Dis
s
osal
Water Quality
Historical accounts point to wastewater treatment as
a relatively modern practice. By the 1920s, wastewater
treatment was a mechanical process involving settling,
skimming off floating materials and removing solids. By
the end of World War II, technological advances made
biological processes possible. In the 1970s when strict
environmental regulations were implemented, these
original systems needed to be upgraded and supple-
mented.
Today's wastewater treatment plants are often com-
plex facilities that use modern technology and reflect
advancements in engineering principles and practices,
chemistry and microbiology. The wastewater field has
a language of its own. A few examples of terms that
might be unfamiliar to the layperson include food-
to-microorganism ratio, sludge age, detention time,
hydraulic loading, organic loading and mean cell reten-
tion time. These terms are often related with complex
mathematical equations that help determine the size
and types of equipment that are needed to clean the
wastewater.
The initial step in the wastewater treatment process
is called
preliminary treatment
and begins as all raw
sewage from domestic and commercial sources enters
the treatment plant at the plant's "headworks."
Wastewater flows through bar screens (influent screens)
typically made of steel or iron bars. Most bar screen
spacing is less than one inch, but bars can be up to several
inches apart. Large objects ranging from trash and toys
to rocks and branches that could clog or damage plant
machinery are mechanically raked and screened out
from the sewage.
After screening, the wastewater enters a grit removal
device.There are several types of devices to remove grit,
but the most common one is a large tank, where the
objects small enough to get through the influent screens
such as sand,coffee grounds,egg shells, jewelry and coins
can sink to the bottom by gravity.The collected debris is
usually hauled off to a landfill for disposal.
After leaving the grit chamber, wastewater is ready for
primary treatment.
During this mostly physical process,
wastewater is piped into primary settling or sedimenta-
tion tanks where heavy particles sink and light particles
float. Mechanical arms slowly move across the top of the
tank collecting the lighter materials like soap, oils and
grease.Sometimes referred to as"scum,"it is skimmed off
the top,and then removed from the tank.Heavier material
that settles to the bottom of the tanks is removed with
mechanical arms that move it to a location where it
can be pumped out to the tanks.This material is called
"primary sludge"or"primary solids."
With very few exceptions, wastewater is further treated
beyond the primary treatment stage.
During
secondary treatment,
biological processes are
incorporated to remove contaminants dissolved in the
wastewater.One of the methods used is called activated
sludge. Wastewater goes into large rectangular tanks,
with air pumped in to promote the growth of naturally
occurring microorganisms that feed on organic materials.
After the microorganisms have absorbed and digested
the organic materials,the wastewater is sent into second-
ary sedimentation tanks (secondary clarifiers),where the
microorganisms eventually settle to the bottom and
are removed.The heavier materials that have settled to
the bottom are called "secondary sludge" or "second-
ary solids." Secondary solids are usually sent to solids
handling facilities for further processing.
By the time secondary treatment is done, 85 percent or
more of the solids and organic materials are removed
from the wastewater. Activated sludge is just one
example of a treatment process that meets secondary
treatment objectives.
The first major wastewater
treatment phase is called
"primary" and uses
screening, skimming and
sedimentation processes.
14
15
Ultraviolet light (UV)
lamps are among the
options for disinfecting
wastewater.
In most situations,secondarytreatment must be followed
by a
disinfection process
to kill harmful pathogens
(protozoa, bacteria and viruses). Chlorine is one of the
most common disinfectants. When chlorine is used, it
is often necessary to remove the chlorine with other
chemicals before the wastewater is put back into the
waterways.There are several other options for disinfect-
ing wastewater such as ultraviolet light disinfection.
Biosolids Management
At most wastewater treatment plants, the scum, primary
solids and secondary solids undergo additional treatment
— often through a process called
anaerobic digestion.
In this process, the material is heated to 100-plus
degrees Fahrenheit in tanks called digesters. The heat,
breakdown of organic material and lack of oxygen in
the digesters destroy pathogens. When the process is
complete,the solids are suitable for recycling as a fertilizer
in certain conditions and are now appropriately called
"biosolids."
Other processes that can be used to turn wastewater
solids into biosolids include composting and heat drying
into pellets.
Many wastewater agencies have managed the solids
remaining after the treatment processes by drying them
in the open air or through belt presses to remove water
and then hauling them to landfills for disposal.
However in recent decades biosolids have gained
recognition as an important resource that can be
recycled. In 1993 EPA published landmark regula-
tions that set standards for safely recycling biosolids.
Under certain circumstances, secondary treatment and
disinfection may not make wastewater clean enough
to release back into the environment. To meet more
stringent public health and environmental regulations,
many wastewater agencies have added more advanced
wastewater treatment processes between secondary
treatment and disinfection.
This additional step is called is called
tertiary treatment,
derived from the Latin word, meaning "of a third," or
advanced treatment.
During these processes, various
methods can be used to remove a variety of constituents.
One form of advanced treatment is filtration, which is
used to remove very small particles.A common filtration
process involves passing wastewater through a bed of
sand or other fine-grained material. Filtration can also
be achieved by passing wastewater through synthetic
microfiltration membranes with very small openings
that leave the particles behind. After sufficient filtration,
wastewater can be used for almost any purpose except
direct human consumption.
Wastewater treatment plants can be designed to remove
nutrients such as nitrogen and phosphorus. This can
be achieved through stand-alone advanced treatment
processes, or the capability can be built-in to certain
types of secondary treatment processes.
Biosolids are also regulated under other laws, including
the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act and Clean
Air Act.
Since these laws passed,wastewater agencies have been
placing an increasing emphasis on ensuring that benefits
of organic matter and nutrients in biosolids are put to
good use.To reduce energy costs and comply with stricter
environmental regulations, and as a result of science and
technology, there are green solutions associated with
solids and biosolids management.
Wastewater agencies are contributing to California's
renewable energy mandate via the production and use of
methane from microbial activity in anaerobic digestion.
In an effort to enhance biogas production,many are now
accepting hauled in organic waste such as fats, oils and
grease and food waste for anaerobic digestion. These
practices not only help fulfill renewable energy mandates
but also help divert organic waste out of landfills,fulfilling
legislative mandates.
As one example, the East Bay Municipal Utility District's
(EBMUD) waste-to-power program uses biogas emitted
by the microorganisms to generate renewable energy to
power its wastewater treatment plant and sell the excess
back to the electrical grid.
A graphic illustrating the city of San Diego's Metro
Biosolids Center and a video can be accessed from
this link: http://www.sandiego.gov/mwwd/facilities/
metrobiosolids.shtml
Before biosolids are recycled as a soil amendment,
fertilizer or compost ingredient, they must comply with
local, state and federal regulations and are tested for
pollutants, including nutrients, pathogens, heavy metals
and synthetic organic compounds. Comprehensive
risk assessments by EPA continue as does research by
universities across the country, including California.
Wastewater agencies also fund research to answer
new or outstanding questions relative to the safety of
biosolids recycling.
Nevertheless some people still have uncertainty
regarding the safety of biosolids recycling. Several local
governments, including counties, have enacted limita-
tions or even bans on beneficial use and are the subject
of litigation.
Water Recycling
Water and wastewater agencies, from large to small and
from all corners of California, are producing and using
recycled water — the highly treated effluent that flows
out of the treatment plant. Recycled water is treated to
meet local, state and federal regulatory guidelines for
its intended end use, which can range from construc-
tion activities and cooling water for powerplants to golf
course irrigation and toilet flushing.
Recycled water increasingly is being used as a viable
water source in California because water management
is shifting away from the construction of new dams and
reservoirs. New water treatment technologies are now
considered a realistic way of maintaining a supply of
water to meet demand.
The California State Legislature has set specific goals
for the amount of water recycling in the future. That
includes increasing the use of recycled water by at least
1 million acre-feet (an acre-foot is about 326,000 gallons
or enough water to fill a football field to a depth of one
foot) per year by 2020, and by at least 2 million acre-feet
per year by 2030.
Purple pipes and related equipment and posted signage
Recycled water is delivered
differentiate a recycled water system from a drinking
through separate purple pipe
water system.
iufrastructure to differentiate
it from the system used to
More information is available in the
Layperson's Guide
to Water Recycling,
published by the Water Education
deliver drinking water.
Foundation. Purchase it online at www.watereducation.
orq or call 916.444.6240.
17
16
Current Challen
I
es
1
organizations. As more scientific research is completed,
Research results from a project report published by the
Aging Wastewater Infrastructure
state and federal agencies continually add requirements
National Water Research Institute on "Source, Fate, and
The cornerstone of municipal wastewater systems is
infrastructure, but it is aging and sometimes stressed by
population growth.There is also the uncertainty of climate
change-related impacts.
To manage the increased wastewater from a population
of 38 million that is projected by the Public Policy Institute
of California to reach 42 million to 48 million people by
2020, wastewater systems and services must expand.
The question, of course, is how to pay for such large but
necessary investments.
Today's Californians are benefiting from local wastewater
systems built during the last century and paid for primar-
ily by federal government funds and grant programs.The
biggest infusion of federal and state funds occurred in the
decade after passing the Clean Water Act in 1972.Current
customer rates and fees reflect those former investments.
According to EPA, treatment plants typically have a use-
ful life of 20 to 50 years before they require expansion or
rehabilitation.Sewer pipes have life cycles that can range
from several decades up to more than 100 years,depend-
ing on the type of material used, where they are located
and how they were installed. EPA has estimated that the
nation must invest $390 billion over the next 20 years to
replace existing wastewater systems and build new ones
to meet increasing demand.
In a similar vein, the American Society of Civil Engineers
(ASCE) Report Card 2012 reported that the state's
infrastructure investment has not kept up with its
growing population demands and is continuing to delay
much-needed renewal and maintenance.
According to the ASCE Report Card,California's infrastruc-
ture earned an overall grade of"C"and needs an additional
annual investment of $65 billion.The state's wastewater
system infrastructure earned a C+.The annual investment
needed to raise its wastewater infrastructure grade from
a C+ to a B is $4.5 billion annually for the next 10 years,
according to the report card.
To finance the long-overdue capital improvement projects
to upgrade or replace existing wastewater systems, a
number of ideas are being discussed in financial circles.
They include creating a long-term federal financing
source such as a federal clean water trust fund that would
leverage public and private funding for infrastructure
projects, including wastewater systems. Financing from
state and local governments could also come via general
obligation bonds, sales taxes, general tax revenues, or
special assessments. Public-private partnerships are
another option.
Without state and federal funding available, the primary
source of revenues for fixing aging wastewater collection
systems and treatment facilities are the fees charged to
individual ratepayers. Under voter-approved Proposition
218, ratepayer approval is necessary before rates can be
increased to pay for operations or capital improvement
projects. Public rate-setting processes include written
notices, known as Proposition 218 notices, and public
hearings. Because municipal wastewater agencies are
governed by city councils, county boards of supervisors
or elected boards, their meetings are always open to the
public, with opportunities available for providing com-
ments. Many agency documents, reports and contracts
are available to the public also.
Constituents of Emerging Concern
A topic in and out of the news and on the minds of
the public is the presence of constituents of emerging
concern (CECs) in water bodies, including wastewater
effluent, which can now be detected by advanced
scientific testing. CECs, a broad and generic term, are
also referred to as emerging constituents, endocrine-
disru pting chemicals (EDCs) or pharmaceuticals and
personal care products. They are also called non-
traditional pollutants.
CECs can be categorized into the following groups:
synthetically and naturally occurring hormones; personal
care products; pharmaceutically active compounds;
pesticides, herbicides and insecticides; industrial and
household chemicals; disinfection by-products; and
metals.
Although they are not directly regulated by the state or
federal government, CECs have the attention of the State
Water Board, which has adopted an amendment to its
Recycled Water Policy related to CECs. Some individual
discharge permits also require monitoring of CECs.
Research and studies continue on CEC issues, including
occurrence;effects on people,animals,aquatic life and the
environmentand treatment methods, by the wastewater
community and state and federal government,along with
other entities such as statewide and national wastewater
to address contaminants when they are proven to be
harmful.
According to the Bureau of Reclamation's "Secondary/
Emerging Constituents Report" (2009), "approximately
87,000 emerging compounds have been identified as
possible EDCs (EPA, 2008)." In its conclusion, the report
explained that, "CECs are diverse compounds whose
characteristics vary even within the same subcategory."
Among the report's recommendations were that
consideration should be given to the following: "The
willingness of the public to pay for potentially costly
mitigation efforts;the importance of CECs in surface water
and drinking water relative to other public health and
environmental concerns; and the potential loss or gain
related to waiting for more information or taking action
despite uncertainties regarding CECs."
Climate Change
According to EPA's Climate Change Basics website,
(www.epa.gov/climatechange/basics),
climate change
"refers to any significant change in the measures of
climate lasting for an extended period of time. In other
words, climate change includes major changes in tem-
perature, precipitation or wind patterns, among other
effects, that occur over several decades or longer."
Breaking down the definition,EPA identifies global warm-
ing as the "recent and ongoing rise in global average
temperature near earth's surface. ... However, global
warming itself represents only one aspect of climate
change."
Impacts that climate change could have on wastewater
and drinking water utilities were detailed in a 104-page
report, "Confronting Climate Change: an Early Analysis
of Water and Wastewater Adaptation Costs," released in
October 2009 by the National Association of Clean Water
Agencies and the Association of the Metropolitan Water
Agencies, prepared by CH2M Hill. The report estimated
the adaptation costs for those facilities could range from
$448 billion to $944 billion through 2050.
"Climate change will impact wastewater utilities on a
number of fronts," the report said. Among the climate-
related challenges addressed in the report were extreme
storm events and overall precipitation increases;the need
for additional flood protection measures such as levees,
seawalls and pumping; and wastewater cooling systems
to protect fisheries due to increased temperatures.
Transport of Endocrine Disruptors, Pharmaceuticals,
and Personal Care Products in Drinking Water Sources
in California" will be used to better assess any potential
health and environmental impacts of CECs.
According to the report,"The total estimated Net Present
Value (NPV) cost of wastewater system climate change
adaptation in the U.S. is between $123 billion and $252
billion above and beyond existing wastewater system
infrastructure upgrade, renewal and replacement pro-
grams that EPA estimates to be between $300 billion and
$500 billion for combined drinking water and wastewater
for the 2007-2027 period.The NPV early estimate includes
both capital and O&M cost estimates."
Wastewater agencies across the state are improving the
energy efficiency of their operations to reduce demands
on fossil fuel energy sources,producing renewable energy
using biogas, solar and wind, and reducing their green-
house gas emissions.They are also developing strategies
to adapt to expected changes in climate.
Among the green efforts agencies are encompassing
include converting from gasoline-fueled vehicle fleets to
cleaner burning, lower emission alternative fuel vehicles
and changing to solar panel installations to generate
electricity.
The California Wastewater Climate Change Group has
for the past several years led an effort for science-based,
cost-effective climate change solutions and served as
a resource for wastewater agencies on climate change
issues. It is a collaboration of the California Association
of Sanitation Agencies, Bay Area Clean Water Agencies,
Central Valley Clean Water Association and Southern
California Alliance of Publicly Owned Treatment Works.
Wastewater agencies operate
laboratories that constantly
monitor wastewater as
it undergoes treatment
processes.
18
19
Because most storm
drains do not connect into
sewer pipes, stormwater
typically travels through
storm drains directly
into lakes, streams and
oceans without undergoing
treatment, although efforts
are underway to clean up
and monitor these nonpoint
sources of pollutants. Right,
Ballona Creek is monitored
for water quality by a
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
DrainWatch volunteer.
Nonpoint Source Pollution
In most areas of California, collection systems that
transport domestic and commercial wastewater to
treatment plants are independent of storm drain systems
designed for flood control that carry runoff from rainfall,
irrigation or other activities.
When it rains, stormwater picks up "nonpoint source"
pollutants on its way to gutters and drains, includ-
ing cigarettes, trash, automotive fluids, used oil, paint,
fertilizers and pesticides, lawn and garden clippings and
pet waste,from streets, parking lots,driveways,yards and
human encampments.Because most storm drains do not
connect into sewer pipes, stormwater pollution travels
in the storm drains directly to lakes, streams and oceans
without being cleaned or treated.
Because most storm drains do not connect into
sewer pipes, stormwater has historically often traveled
through storm drains directly into lakes, streams and
oceans without undergoing treatment, though more
recently stormwater is now often held in detention
basins, allowing pollutants to settle out before the
water is released or it percolates through to ground-
water. Many stormwater agencies now use stormwater
detention basins and other diversion technologies
as well.
The 1987 amendments to the CWA established the
Section 319 Nonpoint Source Management Program.
Updates to the program were released in 1997 and
2012.The program requires that water bodies impaired
by nonpoint sources be identified and for stakeholders
to implement best management practices to reduce
runoff along with monitoring and evaluating progress
on improvements. Unlike with source point regulations,
there are few numeric criteria requirements.
Wastewater agencies are involved in local, regional
and statewide partnerships and associations to protect
watersheds, prevent stormwater pollution and promote
water quality. Examples include the Sacramento Storm-
water Quality Partnership, which includes the county
of Sacramento and cities of Sacramento, Citrus Heights,
Elk Grove, Folsom, Galt and Rancho Cordova; the Fresno
Metropolitan Flood Control District's Clean Stormwater
Grant Program; and the Santa Clara Valley Urban Runoff
Pollution Prevention Program, an association of 15
government agencies in the Santa Clara Valley.
Under EPA's AdoptYour Watershed program (http://water.
epa.gov/action/adopt),
members of the public can get
involved in activities to protect and restore their local
watersheds.
Public Education
Despite the embarrassing "yuck" factor that inevitably
comes up, public education and outreach are critical to
keeping wastewater systems operating 24/7/365. For
example, local and regional campaigns are educating
Californians on how they can change their personal hab-
its to reduce impacts to both their own household sewer
system and also to their community's wastewater system.
Saying it straight out is the Orange County Sanitation
District in its "What to Flush" school education program.
"It's simple, the toilet is only meant to flush the three
P's - pee, poop and paper," the campaign says."Human
waste and toilet paper should be the only thing going
down the toilet. Unfortunately, over the years, people
have turned the toilet into a trash can."
When items like disposable diapers, dental floss, wipes,
facial tissues, paper towels, coffee grounds, sanitary
products, medications, cat box litter, deceased pet fish,
and cigarette butts are flushed down the toilet, they
clog household plumbing, waste water, harm public
sewer systems and the oceans, and add to the cost of
treating and disposing of wastewater - often resulting
in higher utility bills. A dangerous caveat to kitty litter
is Toxoplasmosis, a parasite found in cat waste that is
harmful to marine biology.
To educate customers, the wastewater community has
stepped up its public and school education programs.
For example, the "No Drugs Down the Drain" program,
sponsored by the cities of Los Angeles, Riverside and
San Diego, county of Los Angeles, Inland Empire Utilities
Agency,Orange County Sanitation District and Sanitation
Districts of Los Angeles County with the partnership of
the California Pharmacists Association, includes informa-
tion about the problems with flushing unused, unwanted
and expired medications down the toilet or drain and
offers alternative, safe and proper disposal choices. The
website at www.nodrugsdownthedrain.org/NoDrugs
also offers information by zip code to those living outside
of the sponsors'areas.Similar programs around the state
include the Sonoma County Water Agency Safe Medicine
Disposal program and Sacramento Regional County Sani-
tation District (SRCSD)"Don't Flush Your Meds" program.
The Tahoe City Public Utility District (TCPUD) implores
customers not to throw wipes down the toilet."They can
clog the connection to the sewer line causing backups
resulting in expensive repairs for the homeowners and/or
cause backups that spill sewage into our fragile mountain
environment," the district wrote in a "Wipes Clog Pipes"
flyer."Flushable is a catchy phrase and companies use it
to market their products.The challenge is that wipes can't
break down and more and more of our sewer lines and
pumps are being clogged with these wipes. Please help
us keep sewage in pipes and out of our environment by
not throwing any type of wipe down the toilet."
The proper disposal of fats, oils and grease (called FOG
by the wastewater community) is the focus of many
agency public information programs, especially right
before Thanksgiving and the holiday season. Frying and
cooking oils,salad dressings,soups, meat trimmings and
bacon fat, and greasy leftovers
should never be poured down
the drain because they can
solidify in household and local
agency sewer pipes, clog them
and lead to sewer backups,
overflows into the environment,
and increased customer sewer
rates to pay for sewer mainte-
nance and plumbing repairs.
At the Sacramento Area Sewer
District,F0G-related sewer work
costs approximately $3 million
each year.
TCPUD has free cooking oil/
grease disposal containers for
its customers. The Bay Area
Pollution Prevention Group
(BAPPG), a committee of the Bay Area Clean Water Agen-
cies, uses English,Spanish and Asian radio ad campaigns
during the holidays to focus on the proper disposal of
FOG. A related BAPPG program with the San Francisco
Bay Keeper involved outreach with stores that sell turkey
fryers to include proper FOG disposal information.
Public education efforts also include wastewater treat-
ment plant tours tailored for adults and as part of school
education programs.
Wastewater agencies have also worked with the public to
be good neighbors. In the 1970s SRCSD planned a large
undeveloped buffer area between its regional waste-
water treatment plant and surrounding neighborhoods
in south Sacramento County.The 2,650-acre Bufferlands
has led to conservation of increasingly scarce wetlands,
grasslands and riparian forest habitats. In another
example,as the city of Los Angeles embarks on a 10-Year
L.A. Sewers Construction Program, the Department of
Public Works will use microtunneling technology when-
ever possible to be less disruptive to neighborhoods.
Wastewater agencies host
treatment plant tours as part
of their educational and
public outreach programs.
20
21
Case Studies
The type of wastewater
treatment system a
community will have is
dependent on location,
population and where
the treated water will be
released.
California —the third largest state in land area — is approxi-
mately 156,000 square miles, with an average width of
150 to 200 miles.Mt.Whitney at 14,495 feet is the highest
point in the contiguous United States; Badwater in Death
Valley National Park at 282 feet below sea level is the
lowest elevation point in the United States; and the San
Francisco Bay is the largest natural harbor and estuary,
including the Delta, on the West Coast.
The state's geographical diversities combined with
varying populations and water resources create many
challenges that were recognized by California's legal and
regulatory forefathers when they created nine separate
Regional Water Boards to work within local and regional
parameters in creating wastewater regulatory programs.
Excerpts from Regional Water Board fact sheets illustrate
why different types of wastewater collection, treatment
and disposal systems must be designed, planned, built
and operated to meet the needs of California residents,
industries and visitors,which included 13.6 million inter-
national tourists in 2010.(http://www.visitcalifornia.com
)
The North Coast Region, from the Oregon border
to Marin County, has a 340-mile-long coastline, wet
coastal mountain areas and drier inland valleys,
and timber harvesting, agriculture, recreation and
tourism industries.
The San Francisco Bay Region, home to more than 7
million people, includes high-tech industries in the
Silicon Valley, oil refineries in Contra Costa County
and agriculture — such as vineyards and dairies.
The Central Coast Region, from Santa Clara County
south to northern Ventura County, has 378 miles
of coastline, agriculture, tourism, power and oil
production, and food processing industries.
The Los Angeles Region, with more than 10 million
residents, includes the coastal watersheds of Los
Angeles and Ventura counties, along with portions
of Kern and Santa Barbara counties.
The Central Valley Region is 60,000 square miles
with the Sierra Nevada on the east,coast ranges and
Klamath Mountains on the west, Oregon border on
the north and Tehachapi Mountains on the south.
The Sacramento and San Joaquin rivers and their
tributaries drain the major part of this area through
the Delta into San Francisco Bay.The Bay-Delta is the
focal point of the State Water Project and federal
Central Valley Project.
The La hontan Region, named for a prehistoric
lake, runs from the Oregon border south along
the eastern crest of the Sierra Nevada through
the northern Mojave Desert. Within this area are
hundreds of lakes, including Lake Tahoe and Mono
Lake, streams and wetlands. Tourism ranks as the
most important industry.
The Colorado River Basin Region, which covers the
state's most arid area, has two water bodies of state
and national significance: the Colorado River and
Salton Sea.Colorado River water irrigates more than
700,000 acres of farmland and provides drinking
water to people in the southern coastal cities.
The Santa Ana Region, from the San Bernardino
and San Gabriel mountains in the north and east to
Newport Bay along the coast, is geographically the
smallest at 2,800 square miles but has one of the
largest populations with almost 5 million people.
The San Diego Region is 85 miles of coastline from
Laguna Beach to the Mexican Border. It extends 50
miles inland to the crest of the coastal mountain
range.
What type of wastewater treatment system a community
will have depends on location, population and where
the treated water will be released — whether it will be
discharged in the interior of the state, including lakes,
rivers or streams or the Delta, or along the coastlines
into the ocean. Other disposal methods, including land
application and percolation ponds, which further clean
effluent by filtering it through soil, are also used.
The following case studies describe examples of
discharge programs, an advanced water treatment
project and a wastewater overflow (sewage spill) scenario.
Bay/Ocean Discharge Program
The story behind the city of Los Angeles'Hyperion Treat-
ment Plant — the largest wastewater treatment facility in
Southern California — includes a chronicle of successes
and failures, grassroots efforts and, ultimately, recogni-
tion by the American Public Works Association (APWA)
as one of the 10 Most Outstanding Public Works Projects
of the 20th Century.
In the late 1800s, raw sewage from El Pueblo de Nuestra
Sefiora la Reina de los
Angeles
(the Town of Our Lady
Queen of the Angels) was conveyed through natural
waterways to the ocean.
Los Angeles in 1892 bought 200 acres in Playa del Rey
— south of what is now the Los Angeles International
Airport — for the location of what eventually would be the
Hyperion Treatment Plant. Raw sewage was discharged
into the ocean until 1925 when a simple screen plant
started operation.
The screened wastewater discharged into the ocean did
not prevent beach closures,which only increased with the
growing Los Angeles population. In 1900,the city's popu-
lation totaled more than 100,000; in 1940, it numbered
2.8 million people, according to U.S. Census statistics.
Following World War II,a new plant — the Hyperion Treat-
ment Plant — was planned, funded and built. When it
began operating in 1950, it was the first large secondary
treatment plant on the West Coast and included biosolids
processing. But a population growth spurt and lack of
funds to enlarge the plant impacted levels of treatment,
and water quality standards were rarely met. Discover-
ies by scientists included fish with fin rot and dolphins
with tumors. Surfers and swimmers had skin rashes and
became sick with flu-like symptoms.
According to a news release from APWA,"By 1957, the
new plant was discharging a blend of secondary and
primary effluent through a five-mile ocean outfall. Hy-
perion then stopped its biosolids-to-fertilizer program
and began discharging digested sludge into the Santa
Monica Bay through a separate seven-mile ocean outfall.
Discharging 25 million pounds of wastewater solids per
month began to take its toll on the marine life in Santa
Monica Bay."
Concerned about the pollution in Santa Monica Bay, a
group of Los Angeles area residents founded Heal the
Bay in 1985.Massive grassroots efforts led to major facility
upgrades in the late 1980s and a full secondary treatment
system was rebuilt and opened in 1998.The result: a 95
percent reduction in the amount of wastewater solids
going into Santa Monica Bay.
Hea I the Bay's 2012 End of Summer Beach Report
Card reported that beach water quality statewide was
improved and on the rise, citing continued improve-
ment at Los Angeles County and Santa Monica beaches,
among others.
Research into alternative sustainable biosolids solutions
led to the Terminal Island Renewable Energy (TIRE)
program. TIRE, which is being demonstrated under an
EPA Underground Injection Control permit, puts brine,
treated effluent, biosolids and re-slurried biosolids in
depleted deep subsurface oil and gas formations where
the earth's high temperature biodegrades the organic
compounds to generate methane gas to produce an
environmentally safe renewable energy,while the carbon
dioxide is sequestered, or isolated.
Operating since 1894,
the Hyperion Treatment
Plant is the city of Los
Angeles's oldest and largest
wastewater treatment
facility.
111111111111111111.11•1111111111'
22
23
Inland Surface Water Discharge
The Guardian laboratory
boat crew monitors water
quality and collects water
samples at upstream and
downstream sites of the
wastewater plant discharge
into the Sacramento River.
The Sacramento Regional County Sanitation District
(SRCSD) has embarked on wastewater treatment plant
upgrades to meet new and stricter water quality regula-
tions required by the Central Valley Regional Water Board
for treated water discharged into the Sacramento River
to significantly improve water quality in the Sacramento
River and Delta.
Somme. flegi;o1.0.1
Soni.lien °atria
Discharge to Land
The Fresno/Clovis Regional Water Reclamation Facility,
operated by the city of Fresno, provides wastewater
treatment services for the greater Fresno metropolitan
area in the central San Joaquin Valley.
The plant, located in Fresno, receives 68 million gallons of
wastewater on an average day with the capacity to treat
80 million gallons a day. After primary and secondary
treatment processes, the treated wastewater is directed
to 1,660 acres of ponds to percolate into the ground.
A portion is also supplied directly to nearby farmers to
irrigate fodder and fiber crops, such as alfalfa and cotton.
In 1891 the city began its first sewer system with the
construction of a 24-inch outfall sewer to a 40-acre"sewer
farm" located southwest of Fresno. As the population
grew, additional septic tanks were added to the sewer
farm to provide partial treatment of waste before being
spread on land and used for irrigation.
An 812-acre parcel of property was acquired by the
As background, in late 2010 new permit regulations were
issued. Among other requirements, the permit contains
mandates that require SRCSD to plan, design and con-
struct new treatment facility upgrades for ammonia and
nitrate removal, filtration and disinfection by 2021.
On a fast-track, in 2012 the Adva nced Treatment
Technology Pilot project was constructed to help
SRCSD decide what technology to use in its treat-
ment plant upgrade. The pilot facilities include new
air activated sludge facilities with biological nutrient
removal. Downstream of the activated sludge facilities,
different types of filtration technologies and disinfection
technologies are being tested.
SRCSD provides wastewater conveyance and treat-
ment services to residential, industrial and commercial
customers throughout unincorporated Sacramento
County, the cities of Citrus Heights, Elk Grove, Folsom,
Rancho Cordova, Sacramento and West Sacramento
and the communities of Courtland and Walnut Grove.
Under this regional system, wastewater travels through
177 miles of pipelines to a treatment plant south of
Sacramento in Elk Grove, where approximately 150
million gallons of wastewater are treated each day and
discharged into the Sacramento River.
city in 1909 and would become the site of the current
facilities. In the meantime, to cope with the demands of
the city and agriculture, more acreage was purchased and
more septic tanks were installed. Even the groundwater
elevation was lowered to increase percolation capacity.
A major new treatment plant was constructed in 1947 to
provide primary treatment to sewage before continued
land disposal and local irrigation use. Population growth
required a second plant in 1958.
In 1966 the city was designated as the sewering agency
for the local metropolitan area and assumed the role
of developing a long-range, area-wide wastewater
treatment and disposal plan. After the Clean Water Act
was passed, major construction projects improved
facilities to meet water quality requirements. Due to
more population growth, the latest plant expansions
were in the late 1990s. A cogeneration facility uses
the methane gas to partially meet the plant's energy
requirements.
Alternative Treatment
The city of Arcata's Marsh and Wildlife Sanctuary on the
North Coast is also home to a unique wastewater treat-
ment facility that uses alternative technology to remove
wastewater contaminants. The 307-acre ecosystem on
the north end of Humboldt Bay integrates conventional
treatment processes with the natural processes of fresh-
water marshes. Salt marsh, tidal sloughs, grassy uplands,
mudflats and a brackish marsh provide habitat for wildlife.
Located along the Pacific Flyway, the sanctuary provides
wetland habitat for more than 300 species of birds and
numerous species of mammals, amphibians, insects and
plants.There are also approximately five miles of walking
and biking trails and the Arcata Marsh Interpretive Center.
But at one time, the marsh was the site of the county
landfill, and became known as"MountTrashmore."Klopp
Lake was originally a leachate basin for the landfill.
The first water treatment plant in 1949 offered only
primary treatment, releasing un-chlorinated effluent into
the Arcata Bay. In 1957,55 acres of oxidation ponds were
added for a secondary treatment process. Chlorination
was
added in 1966 and
an additional process was added
in 1975 to remove the remaining chlorine.
With the arrival of the Clean Water Act,the county landfill
located next to the primary and secondary wastewater
treatment plant was closed in 1973 and restored to a
grassy upland.To comply with the new federal law, plans
for a new regional treatment facility were proposed
in 1975, but the citizens of Arcata eyed the plan with
skepticism. Among the reasons were the large energy
requirements for pumping sewage to the plant and the
potential for breaks in the pipes crossing the bay posed
environmental concerns.
Instead the community, including city officials and a
group of professors from the local university, proposed
an alternative wastewater treatment facility.Pilot projects
were successful, and on July 4, 1981, the original Arcata
Marsh and Wildlife Sanctuary covering 75 acres was
dedicated. In 1983 the State Water Resources Control
Board permits allowed Arcata to upgrade its wastewater
treatment plant, including wetland treatment enhance-
ment units.
As a result of the marsh system, the effluent finally
discharged into Humboldt Bay has gone through
enhanced secondary treatment.
The city of Arcata's Marsh
and Wildlife Sanctuary
on the North Coast is
also home to a unique
wastewater treatment
facility that uses alternative
technology to remove
wastewater contaminants.
24
Advanced Water Treatment
After wastewater is treated to a secondary level at the
of ultra-pure water produced since going on-line in
Orange County Sanitation District (OCSD), some of it
January 2008.
goes to the ocean and some of it flows to the Ground-
water Replenishment System (GWRS) in Fountain Valley
In February 2012, OCWD broke ground on the GWRS
where it undergoes a state-of-the-art purification pro-
Initial Expansion, which will result in the production of
cess consisting of microfiltration, reverse osmosis and
100 million gallons per day beginning in early 2015.
ultraviolet light with hydrogen peroxide. As a result, the
treated water is described as near-distilled quality.
It is the world's largest advanced water purification
facility of its kind, with a daily output of 70 million
gallons.Approximately 35 million gallons per day of the
treated water are pumped into injection wells to create a
seawater intrusion barrier.Another 35 million gallons are
pumped daily to Orange County Water District's (OCWD)
percolation basins in Anaheim where the water from the
system naturally filters through sand and gravel to the
aquifers of the groundwater basin.
The system has also been used to provide peak waste-
water disposal flow relief and indefinitely postponed
the need for OCSD to construct a new ocean outfall by
recycling wastewater flows that would otherwise be
discharged to the Pacific Ocean.
Called the largest advanced wastewater treatment
facility of its kind in the world, the system is a joint
OCWD/OCSD project. It reached a major milestone
on Dec. 10, 2012, when it marked 100 billion gallons
Wastewater Overflow Scenario
An"atmospheric river"hit the Sonoma Valley in late 2012.
and replacement projects, including the installation of
As a result of the extraordinary amount of heavy rainfall
five smart cover maintenance hole alarm systems.Smart
that inundated the area, two wastewater overflows
covers on maintenance holes send alarms to sanitation
occurred within the Sonoma Valley County Sanitation
staff when a wastewater collection pipe nears its capac-
District.
ity. Staff can then respond to the appropriate location
and pump wastewater into a collection truck to prevent
As required by the State Water Board, the district has
an overflow.
developed a Sewer System Management Plan, which
describes how the sewer collection system is oper-
During a 1995 Sonoma County government restruc-
ated, maintained and evaluated. Its contents range from
turing, the Sonoma County Water Agency assumed
goals and an operations and maintenance program to
responsibility for managing the county sanitation
emergency response and communications plans. For
zones and districts that provide wastewater treatment,
example, if a spill occurs, wastewater maintenance and
reclamation and disposal services. County sanitation
work crews, including biologists, collect wastewater
districts are separate legal entities; sanitation zones are
samples, evaluate environmental impacts and monitor
owned by the water agency. Each sanitation zone and
the collection systems.
district operates under a unique, individual permit from
the San Francisco Bay Regional Water Board or North
To help reduce overflows during large storms, the
Coast Regional Water Board that set the requirements
sanitation district has ongoing pipeline improvement
for their operations.
The Orange County
Sanitation District has the
world's largest advanced
water purification facility
of its kind with a daily
output of 70 million
gallons. Currently the
plant is undergoing
expansion.
The Future
California's publicly owned wastewater systems are pub-
lic assets confronting a challenging future. Could future
wastewater and sanitation issues be even more complex
than those of the past?
In its 2020 Vision for Clean Water,the National Association
of Clean Water Agencies,Water Environment Federation
and Association of Clean Water Administrators wrote,"We
have inherited the water quality and infrastructure of the
20th century from our parents and grandparents — our
children and grandchildren deserve the same from us in
the 21st century."
Their goals,embraced by California wastewater agencies,
include the following:
Developing holistic watershed approaches that can
effectively address the diffuse and complex sources
of water pollution that hinder additional progress.
Ensuring that maximum flexibility,creativity,author-
ity, and innovation under the Clean Water Act are
supported and barriers that may stand in the way
of these objectives are addressed.
Spreading awareness of the value of the nation's
water, including the vital role of water and waste-
water infrastructure in job creation, economic
expansion and public health protection.
Maximizing the effect of limited human and capital
resources by focusing on the initiatives and projects
that achieve the greatest water quality gains relative
to the collective effort invested.
Ensuring that municipalities and states have the
funds and financial tools needed to implement
programs that will ensure 40 more years of clean
water improvements.
California's wastewater community is very focused on the
replacement and improvement of aging infrastructure
and the issue of how to pay for these future investments
that are as crucial in this century as in the last century.
It is important to realize that wastewater rates paid by
most Californians today reflect past infusions of federal
and state money. In other words, many people are not
paying the full cost of wastewater infrastructure through
their rates and fees.
Wastewater entities also face potential obstacles that
were not considered or planned for in the previous
century. For example, the state's wastewater infrastruc-
ture is not immune from the impacts of future extreme
wet weather events that could cause power outages at
treatment plants. Planning for these natural disasters
and climate change variables is front and center for
wastewater agency managers in their efforts to prevent
degraded water quality and protect the environment.
Look for wastewater agency managers to implement
integrated planning processes and take advantage of
more sustainable and comprehensive solutions to reach
water quality objectives.
There will be increased interaction with the general
public and policy leaders as people become increasingly
aware of how their own activi-
ties and the associated impact
of contaminants from those
activities impact wastewater
treatment, clean water and the
environment.
As science and technology
make possible advanced wa-
ter quality testing from de-
tecting compounds at parts-
per-million (1 part compound
to 1 million parts water) to
parts-per-billion levels to parts-
per-trillion levels, the detect-
able occurrence of CECs needs
thoughtful public discussions.
For example, when a new pol-
lutant compound is detected,
is there a health concern, or at
what level does it become a
health or environmental con-
cern? If yes, who pays for costs
to remove it from the waste-
water?
Also on the radar are discus-
sions on how treatment plants
fit under the California Air Re-
sources Board's"cap and trade"
program as part of implemen-
tation of California's Assembly
Bill 32 — The Global Warming
Solutions Act of 2006. Oppor-
tunities could exist in the future
for wastewater agencies to generate revenue through
producing carbon offsets and to contribute to meeting air
pollution reduction goals in a number of different ways.
What might the next generation of sanitation look like?
It could be the solar-powered portable toilet by environ-
mental scientist and engineer Michael Hoffmann of the
California Institute ofTechnology (Caltech). His toilet uses
the sun to power an electrochemical reactor.The reactor
breaks down water and human waste into fertilizer and
hydrogen, which can be stored in hydrogen fuel cells as
energy.The treated water could then be reused to flush
the toilet or for irrigation.
Today's California public
agency wastewater
professionals are state-
certified and at work
around the clock 2417 365
days of the year.
26
27
A future model for the wastewater agency is detailed in
a report titled
The Water Resources Utility of the Future:A
Blueprint for Action."It
contemplates a new business ap-
proach where instead of simply collecting, treating and
disposing of municipal and industrial wastewater, the
utility of the future recognizes that its inputs are valuable
resources,"according to an excerpt."As such, its objectives
are to separate, extract, reuse or convert valuable water,
energy and commodities from wastewater while using
utility assets in innovative ways to reduce costs, increase
revenues and strengthen the local economy."The report
was released in early 2013 by the National Association
of Clean Water Agencies, Water Environment Research
Foundation and Water Environment Federation.
Certified Wastewater Professionals
California's track record of safe and effective operations of wastewater treatment plants can be attributed to
State Water Board certification standards for people working in the wastewater field.There are five levels of
state-mandated wastewater treatment plant operator certification (Grades l-V) and requirements include a
combination of education, training and experience.
Beyond the state-mandated certifications required for wastewater treatment plant operators, the California
Water Environment Association offers voluntary education, training and certification in other vocations in
the water quality field.
Voluntarily surpassing mandatory regulations, California public agencies are attaining certification for hav-
ing environmental management system-based Biosolids Management Programs. This ongoing multi-level
certification program is offered through the Water Environment Federation, in collaboration with the National
Association of Clean Water Agencies and local and regional biosolids management organizations across the
U.S. and Canada with support from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
Looking to the future,the wastewater community is preparing for succession planning as retirements loom for
veteran wastewater professionals.Wastewater agencies are involved in providing educational opportunities
for people interested in pursuing a career in the wastewater field. For example, Laney College and EBMUD
teamed up to offer a pre-apprenticeship level course of study to prepare students for plumbing careers in
the water distribution industry.
References
Thank you for the historical background researched and collected by Jon Schladweiler, a historian with the
Arizona Water Company. www.sewerhistory.org
National Water Research Institute "Source, Fate, and Transport of Endocrine Disruptors, Pharmaceuticals, and
Personal Care Products in Drinking Water Sources in California' Project Report: www.nwri-usa.org/pdfs/
NWRIFinalReportEDCsPPCPsMay2010.pdf
Bureau of Reclamation's "Secondary/Emerging Constituents Report" (2009): www.usbrgov/lc/socal/reports/
brineconcentrate/4SecondaryConstituents.pdf
onfronting Climate Change:An Early Analysis of Water and Wastewater Adaptation Costs": www.amwa.net/
galleries/climatechange/ConfrontingClimateChangeOct09.pdf
"A Citizen's Guide to the California Water Boards":www.waterboards.ca.gov/publications forms/publications/
general/docs/citizenguide2011.pdf State Water Board Office of Public Participation:916.341.5254 or info@
waterboards.ca.gov
.
P
IPThe Water Resources Utility of the Future:A
Blueprint for Action": www.nacwa.org/images/stories/public/2013-
,
01
-
31
waterresourcesutilityofthefuture-final.oclf
28