Some Animals Are More Equal than Others: Trophic Cascades and Keystone Species
Short Film
Student Handout
Refer to Figure 1 for questions 8 through 11 below.
8. In 1997, which species is the apex predator in the food chain? _______
a. Killer whales
b. Sea otters
c. Sea urchins
d. Kelp
9. Which of the following statements describes the data in Figure 1? _______
a. An increase in sea urchin biomass is associated with more intense grazing.
b. An increase in sea urchin biomass is associated with greater kelp density.
c. Predation of sea otters by killer whales is associated with greater kelp density.
d. Sea otter abundance was relatively stable from 1972 to 1997.
10. Complete the blanks in the following sentence from the multiple-choice selections below.
Figure 1 illustrates that when orcas started eating sea otters, the sea otter population [blank 1], the urchin
population [blank 2], and the kelp population [blank 3]. _______
a. decreased, decreased, decreased
b. decreased, increased, decreased
c. increased, decreased, increased
d. increased, increased, increased
11. The arrows on the left and right sides of Figure 1 show the effects of one species on the species that are on
lower trophic levels. Thicker arrows indicate a large effect and thin arrows a smaller effect. The arrows on
the left show a system in which there are a lot of sea otters. The arrows on the right show a system in which
there are few otters. Explain why the down-pointing arrows on the left side of the figure look different from
the arrows on the right side of the figure.
In the 1990s, ecologists Deborah Letourneau and Lee Dyer studied a tropical forest shrub called the piper plant
and the various species of insects that live on and near the shrub. A species of ant uses the piper plant as a
home by hollowing out some of its branches and building colonies inside the hollow branch cores. The ants do
not eat the plant’s leaves. Instead, the leaves are consumed mostly by caterpillars. When the ants encounter
caterpillars or caterpillar eggs on the plant’s leaves, they either eat them or kick them off. Letourneau and Dyer
added beetles that eat ants. Figure 2 shows the results of one of Letourneau and Dyer’s experiments in which
they compared the leaf area of piper plants in control plots to that of experimental plots to which they had
added beetles that eat ants.