Implementing Fiscal and Monetary Policy to Resolve an
Economic Crisis
v1.2
The Presidents
Dilemma
Interact
Click here to find additional titles. www.teachinteract.com
From 'The President's Dilemma'. Product code INT265.
Interact. (800) 359-0961. http://www.teachinteract.com/
All rights reserved. Interaction Publishers Inc. grants permission to reproduce activity sheets and
student handouts for classroom use. No other part of this publication may be reproduced in whole or
in part, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means—electronic, mechanical,
photocopying, recording, or otherwise—without prior written permission from the publisher.
Product Code: INT265
©2010 Interact
10200 Jefferson Blvd. P.O. Box 802 Culver City, CA 90232
Phone: (800) 359-0961 www.teachinteract.com
ISBN# 978-1-56004-642-4
About the Buck Institute for Education
The Buck Institute for Education (BIE) is dedicated to
improving 21st-century teaching and learning by creating and
disseminating products, practices, and knowledge for effective
Project Based Learning. Founded in 1987, BIE is a not-for-profit
501(c)3 organization that receives operational funding from the
Leonard and Beryl Buck Trust, and funding from other education
organizations, foundations, schools and school districts, state
educational agencies, and national governments for product
development, professional development, and research.
Project Based Economics
Authors
Nan Maxwell, PhD
John Larmer
John Mergendoller, PhD
Yolanda Bellisimo
BIE Production Editor
Suzie Boss
Interact Production Editor
Justin Coffey
From 'The President's Dilemma'. Product code INT265.
Interact. (800) 359-0961. http://www.teachinteract.com/
Contents
©2010 Interact | www.teachinteract.com The President’s Dilemma Teacher Guide iii
Table of Contents
Foreword ..................................................1
Introduction
.............................................3
Chapter One .............................................. 3
Teaching Economics With Project Based Learning
. . . . . 8
Chapter Two
.............................................. 8
Teaching Strategies for Project Based Economics
.......10
Chapter Three:
Sample lesson—Make More Money?
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
Letter From AJ
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22
Guidelines for Conducting the
Interview and Playing the Role of AJ
. . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
Median Earnings for
Full-time, Year-Round Workers
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
Chapter Four:
The President’s Dilemma .....................25
Purpose and Overview .................................25
Daily Directions......................................28
Teaching The President’s Dilemma . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28
Step-by-Step Teaching Guide
..........................30
Teacher Materials....................................47
Economics Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47
Monetary Policy
........................................47
Fiscal Policy
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48
From 'The President's Dilemma'. Product code INT265.
Interact. (800) 359-0961. http://www.teachinteract.com/
Contents
iv The President’s Dilemma Teacher Guide ©2010 Interact | www.teachinteract.com
Table of Contents
Concept Definitions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51
Assessment Tools
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55
Questions From Panel Members
.......................55
Rubrics
.................................................58
Test for The Presidents Dilemma Answer Key
. . . . . . . . . . 62
Student Materials....................................67
Memo From the President . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67
National Statistics For Selected Years
..................68
Letters From Constituent Groups
......................69
Memo From the Chief of Staff
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 72
Test for The Presidents Dilemma
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73
Teacher Feedback Form..........................78
Release Form for
Photographic Images ............................79
From 'The President's Dilemma'. Product code INT265.
Interact. (800) 359-0961. http://www.teachinteract.com/
Purpose and Overview
©2010 Interact | www.teachinteract.com The President’s Dilemma Teacher Guide 25
The President’s Dilemma
Chapter Four
Purpose and Overview
Time required
10–12 class periods
Project scenario
In a mixed-market economy like the United States, the federal government
uses fiscal and monetary policy tools to influence the behavior of individuals,
firms, and financial institutions. However, in attempting to improve the
performance of the nations economy, the government encounters the
problem of resource scarcity. Tradeoffs must be considered; some groups
may be harmed in order to help another group in society. To explore these
concepts and gain some understanding of macroeconomic analysis, students
are presented with the following problem-solving scenario in this project:
Due to a rapid rise in oil prices, the United States is facing a severe economic
crisis with high levels of inflation, high unemployment, and slow economic
growth. The President, whose approval ratings are plummeting, has asked
a Special Task Force of the Council of Economic Advisors to recommend
a policy to deal with the crisis without increasing the national debt. The
Task Force is asked to make an oral presentation with visual aides to a
panel composed of representatives of constituencies that have a targeted
interest in the economic solution proposed. As students learn about leading
economic indicators and fiscal and monetary policy, letters arrive from
three panel members. Each constituent argues for policies that benefit
their interest group—unemployed middle-class workers, retired people,
and business representatives. Students must consider both supply-side and
demand-side options and weigh the costs and benefits of various solutions
as they recommend policies that balance the needs of the nation.
Concepts to be learned
To successfully resolve the problem and complete the products required in
this project, students need to understand and be able to apply the following
economic concepts:
10–12 class periods
From 'The President's Dilemma'. Product code INT265.
Interact. (800) 359-0961. http://www.teachinteract.com/
Purpose and Overview
26 The President’s Dilemma Teacher Guide ©2010 Interact | www.teachinteract.com
Budget deficit•
Consumer price index•
Contractionary policy•
Cost-push inflation•
Demand•
Demand-side theories•
Discount rate•
Crowding out•
Economic indicators•
Expansionary policy•
Federal reserve system•
Fiscal policy•
Government spending•
Gross Domestic Product (GDP)•
Inflation•
Interest rates•
Monetary policy•
Multiplier•
National debt•
Open market operations•
Opportunity cost•
Reserve requirement•
Scarcity•
Supply•
Supply-side theories•
Tax•
Tradeoffs•
Unemployment rate•
From 'The President's Dilemma'. Product code INT265.
Interact. (800) 359-0961. http://www.teachinteract.com/
Purpose and Overview
©2010 Interact | www.teachinteract.com The President’s Dilemma Teacher Guide 27
NCEE content standards addressed
The President’s Dilemma addresses the following Voluntary National Content
Standards in Economics codified by The National Council on Economic
Education, in partnership with the National Association of Economic
Educators and the Foundation for Teaching Economics. For more information
see www.ncee.net/ea/standards.
Standard # Economic Concept
1 Scarcity
2 Opportunity cost
12 Interest rates
15 Investment
18 Gross Domestic Product
19 Unemployment and inflation
20 Fiscal and monetary policy
From 'The President's Dilemma'. Product code INT265.
Interact. (800) 359-0961. http://www.teachinteract.com/
©2010 Interact | www.teachinteract.com The President’s Dilemma Teacher Guide 51
Teacher Materials
Concept Definitions
Concept Definitions
The curriculum is designed to teach the following concepts:
Budget deficit: A situation where the flow of expenditures exceeds the
flow of income for the federal government. A deficit occurs when taxes
on income and expenditures are insufficient to meet the payments for
goods and services and interest on the national debt. Contrast with
national debt.
Consumer Price Index (CPI): A measure of the average price of a fixed
market basket of consumer goods and services that are commonly
bought by households. This statistic is computed monthly by the Bureau
of Labor Statistics.
Contractionary policy: A decrease in aggregate demand or supply that is
brought about by a decrease in government spending, an increase in
taxes, or a combination of the two (fiscal policy) or a decrease in money
supply (monetary policy). Contractionary policies are used when the
economy is overheating.
Cost-push inflation arises with sustained increases in the cost of production
that cause the price of the product to increase
Crowding out”: When the federal government borrows money, the
associated rise in interest rates decreases planned investment spending
by private firms and individuals. As a result, government expenditures are
said to crowd out those by private firms.
Demand: Purchases of a good or service that people are actually able and
willing to make, given prices and choices available to them. The “law of
demand” states that there is a negative (or inverse) relationship between
price and quantity demanded. That is, as price increases (decreases) the
amount of a good purchased decreases (increases). Consumers’ demand
is determined by their tastes, income, and price of other goods. The
demand schedule is a table showing the quantities of a good that will
be purchased at various prices. The demand curve is a curve that relates
the price of a product and the quantity of the product that individuals are
able and willing to purchase. Aggregate demand is the total demand
for goods and services in the economy by households (for consumer
goods), by firms and government (for investment goods), and by other
countries (exports).
Demand-push inflation arises when aggregate demand exceeds aggregate
supply and consumers bid up prices
From 'The President's Dilemma'. Product code INT265.
Interact. (800) 359-0961. http://www.teachinteract.com/
52 The President’s Dilemma Teacher Guide ©2010 Interact | www.teachinteract.com
Teacher Materials
Concept Definitions
Demand-side theories: Views that emphasize increasing aggregate demand
as a means of maintaining economic stability in the economy. Should
the economy be at the downturn of the business cycle, demand-side
theorists believe that aggregate demand should be stimulated through
expansionary policies. Should the economy be overheating, demand-side
theorists believe that aggregate demand should be slowed through
contractionary policies.
Discount rate: The rate of interest at which the Federal Reserve lends to the
banking system. Short-term interest rates are geared to the discount rate
through the banking system. If the capital market thinks that changes in
the rate are likely to last for some time, long-term rates will also change.
Economic indicators: Statistics about the economy that allow analysis of
current economic performance and predictions of future performance
Expansionary policy: An increase in aggregate demand or supply brought
about by an increase in government spending, a decrease in taxes, or
a combination of the two (fiscal policy) or an increase in money supply
(monetary policy). Expansionary policies are used when the economy
needs to be stimulated.
Federal Reserve System: The central banking system in the United States.
The system consists of 12 regional banks and branches under control
of the Federal Reserve Board. Although the Governors of the Board are
appointed by the President of the United States, the financial capital of
the reserve banks is owned by the member banks, making the “Fed” an
independent agency. The Board effectively acts as a central bank and
approves the discount rate and reserve ratio, and generally regulates the
operation of the banking system. The Federal Open Market Committee, a
subcommittee of the Board, effectively has the power to influence money
supply through open market operations.
Fiscal policy: An attempt to attain certain economic goals, such as achieving
full employment and increasing Gross Domestic Product (GDP), by
varying the governments purchases of goods and services and its rate of
taxation. The spending authorization and rates of taxation are established
by Congress.
Government spending: Payments for goods, services, and interest made by
the government. Fiscal policy includes the amount spent for goods and
services by the federal government. The multiplier effect associated with
government spending results from spending by any level of government.
Gross Domestic Product (GDP): The dollar value of all final goods and
services produced by resources located in the country during a year
From 'The President's Dilemma'. Product code INT265.
Interact. (800) 359-0961. http://www.teachinteract.com/
©2010 Interact | www.teachinteract.com The President’s Dilemma Teacher Guide 53
Teacher Materials
Concept Definitions
Inflation: An upward movement in the average level of prices. The result
is diminished purchasing power of a given sum of money. Inflation
is contrasted with deflation, which is a downward movement in the
average level of prices. Demand-push inflation arises when aggregate
demand exceeds aggregate supply and consumers bid up prices. Cost-
push inflation arises with sustained increases in the cost of production
that cause the price of the product to increase.
Interest rates: The price of loanable funds, which is usually expressed as
annual percentage and measures the yearly cost of borrowing. The price
paid per dollar borrowed per period of time. Nominal interest rates: The
interest rate taken at its face value (that is, the interest rate expressed
in current dollars and not adjusted for inflation). Real interest rates:
The actual return to capital. Because comparing nominal interest rates
includes a purely monetary component, the value of the rate must be
purged of changes in prices to be compared over time. The rate obtained
after eliminating the element of price change is the real interest rate.
Monetary policy: An attempt to attain certain economic goals, such as
lowering the rate of unemployment or inflation. This can be done by
varying the money supply, interest, and (in some cases) conditions
of credit. The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve establishes
the policies.
Multiplier: The recipients of income will save a portion and spend a portion
of it. Of the portion spent, the income generated to the next recipient will
be partially saved and partially spent. The result of this continued pattern
is that the total increase in aggregate income will, in the end, be several
times larger than the increase in the initial income received (that is, it will
be some multiple of the increase in initial income). The expression that
gives the value of this multiple is the multiplier.
National debt: The total amount of money owed by the federal government
to the owners of government securities. It is equal to the sum of the past
budget deficits (less budget surpluses). Contrast with budget deficit.
Open market operations: The buying and selling of federal government
securities by the Federal Reserve banks
Opportunity costs: The real sacrifice involved in achieving something. The
value of the next best opportunity that is foregone in order to achieve a
particular thing.
Reserve requirements: The proportion of deposits that a bank or other
depository institution is legally required to hold in cash reserve. The
proportion is set by the Federal Reserve as a monetary policy tool.
From 'The President's Dilemma'. Product code INT265.
Interact. (800) 359-0961. http://www.teachinteract.com/
54 The President’s Dilemma Teacher Guide ©2010 Interact | www.teachinteract.com
Teacher Materials
Concept Definitions
Scarcity: A condition where less of something exists than people would like
if the good had no cost. Scarcity arises because resources are limited and
cannot accommodate all of our unlimited wants.
Supply: The amount of a good or service that firms are prepared to sell
at a given price. The firm determines how much of a good to supply
using its marginal cost curve. Industry supply is the summation of all
individual firms’ marginal cost curves (in a constant cost industry). The
supply schedule is a table showing the amount of a product that will
be produced at a given price. The supply curve relates the quantity of
a good supplied by a firm (or market) and each price. The law of supply
dictates that the curve is upsloping, indicating that more will be produced
as the price of the good increases. Aggregate supply is the total amount
of goods and services available for consumption and consists of both
domestically produced goods and services and imports.
Supply-side theories: Views that emphasize increasing aggregate supply
as a means of maintaining economic stability. Should the economy be
at the downturn of the business cycle, supply-side theorists believe that
aggregate supply should be stimulated through expansionary policies.
Should the economy be overheating, supply-side theorists believe that
aggregate supply should be slowed through contractionary policies.
Tax: A compulsory transfer of money from individuals, institutions, or groups
to the government. The tax may be based on either wealth or income or
as a surcharge to prices. Taxation is one of the key elements in fiscal policy
and a primary means by which a government finances its expenditures.
Tradeoff: An exchange relationship denoting how much of one good (or
resource) is needed to get another good (or resource).
Unemployment rate: The number of people able and willing to work
expressed as a percentage of the labor force. Labor force includes
working individuals and unemployed individuals but does not include
individuals who do not wish to work (e.g., retirees).
From 'The President's Dilemma'. Product code INT265.
Interact. (800) 359-0961. http://www.teachinteract.com/