2
Performance Level
Exceeds Minimum
Requirements
Meets Minimum
Requirements
Problematic Unacceptable
Content is delivered in such a way
that students are able to retain and
apply that content.
Consider the effectiveness of:
Resources provided to aid
in learning
Questions asked to gauge
learning
Hands-on applications of
concepts
Quantity and complexity of
information delivered (too
much/too little)
Instructional delivery
methods effectively
engage students in
such a way that they
are able to effectively
retain and apply the
content.
Instructional delivery
methods engage
motivated students in
such a way that they
are able to effectively
retain and apply the
content; less
motivated students
may struggle.
Instructional delivery
methods make it
challenging for even the
most motivated
students to retain and
apply the content.
Instructional delivery
methods are
significantly
ineffective, seriously
affecting students’
ability to retain and
apply the content.
Notes (Highlights/Suggestions):
Graded Coursework and Materials
Yes No
Instructor has provided the evaluator with a sufficient amount of graded material
Performance Level
Exceeds Minimum
Requirements
Meets Minimum
Requirements
Problematic Unacceptable
The graded coursework mirrors ATU’s
main campus counterpart. Graded
material would include, but is not
limited to, homework, papers,
portfolios, labs, quizzes, tests, etc.
Coursework and
grades mirror ATU’s
counterpart.
Coursework and
grades are similar to
ATU’s counterpart.
Coursework and grades
loosely resemble ATU’s
counterpart.
Coursework and
grades deviate from
ATU’s counterpart in
that the material is
not being addressed
or appropriately
graded.
Notes (Highlights/Suggestions):
Performance Level
Exceeds Minimum
Requirements
Meets Minimum
Requirements
Problematic Unacceptable
Field/Discipline Knowledge
Applied to Teaching
It is noticeable through the
observation of the course that the
instructor keeps up to date within the
industry through discipline-specific
professional development,
involvement in that field, or by other
means. The instructor applies that
knowledge to the class appropriately.
Instructor is current
within the industry and
appropriately applies
that knowledge to the
class.
Instructor is current
within the industry
and occasionally
applies that
knowledge to the
class.
Instructor is current
within the industry, but
rarely applies that
knowledge to the class.
Instructor is not
current within the
industry and teaches
material that is not up
to date with current
trends.
Notes (Highlights/Suggestions):