We’ve developed a number of guides and worksheets to help make Check-in successful. ey align to the
three phases of Check-in – Expectations, Feedback, and Development. e following documents are enclosed
in this toolkit.
Expectations
Expectations discussion guide for employees
Expectations discussion guide for managers
Expectations worksheet
Feedback
Feedback discussion guide for employees
Feedback discussion guide for managers
Development
Development discussion guide for employees
Development discussion guide for managers
Individual development plan
Adobe's Check-in Toolkit
Role Modeling Check-in
Leading@Adobe
Directions for using
this guide:
ese discussion guides are intended
to help provide a format and talking
points for employees and people
managers during Check-ins. e guides are
organized by the three steps of Check-in:
Expectations, Feedback and Development and provide
suggestions for how to have an eective discussion. ey are not intended to be a script, but to provide
guidelines to prepare employees and people managers before, during and aer the Check-in
conversation.
Best practices for Check-in
e purpose of Check-in is to make sure employees' expectations are clear, share feedback, and discuss
development needs to enhance their performance. e ow of Check-in follows three core steps:
1. Expectations: First, agree what is expected of employees for the year in terms of deliverables, behavior
and contributions.
2. Feedback: Next, provide frequent, two-way feedback to see how employees are progressing against
expectations and let managers know if they could be doing something dierently to beer support the
employee.
3. Development: en, when employees know how they are performing, they can plan actionable goals
in terms of learning, career and experience.
When should Check-ins happen?
Managers should set up a regular cadence of Check-ins for all employees that ts the needs of their team, but
the following guidelines are recommended:
Check-ins should be scheduled at least once a quarter and typically, are 60-90 minutes long.
Expectations should be set in a Check-in at the beginning of Q1 to clarify objectives for the
year ahead.
Feedback can be provided throughout the year, not only in Check-ins.
Development-focused Check-ins are driven by the employee and should be scheduled when they feel
appropriate. Typically, development conversations may happen once or twice per year.
Expectations Discussion Guide
For Employees
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright © 2010-2015 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All rights reserved.
EXPECTATIONS: Discussion Guide for Employees
Guidelines:
Take time to do this well: Clear expectations are key to an effective relationship with your manager.
Use the expectations worksheet to start mapping out your goals.
Come to the meeting prepared to review a draft of your SMART goals.
Remember: Expectations must be tangible and measurable, not just aspirational.
Ask a lot of questions.
Follow-Through:
Finalize your expectations and share with your manager.
Before your next Check-in, reflect on progress made. What has been harder/easier than you thought?
Regularly ask for business context.
Regularly ask for informal feedback, not only in your Check-in meetings.
“Over the next period of time (e.g. sprint, quarter), what are the critical priorities that we must
accomplish?
Check your understanding of the business context: “How does our team support Adobe? What are
your big bets for the next year?
What key deliverables should I aim for this year?”
1. Context
Review your expectations worksheet with your manager and complete your goals together:
“Do you think these goals are stretching enough for me? Am I being unrealistic?
“How will I be measured on these?
Are these properly aligned to the business goals? If not, how can I ensure that they are?
2. SMART
Confirm how often you would like to review progress: weekly/monthly/quarterly.
Confirm your immediate next steps, (e.g., finalize SMART goals).
Take the opportunity to double-check your understanding of what is expected of you.
4. Review
Have specific tasks tied to the expectations. Not just what will be achieved, but HOW.
“From your experience, what obstacles should I anticipate?”
Who else should I connect with to help achieve these expectations?
What other resources do you think I will need?
3. Obstacles
Role Modeling Check-in
Leading@Adobe
Directions for using
this guide:
ese discussion guides are intended
to help provide a format and talking
points for employees and people
managers during Check-ins. e guides are
organized by the three steps of Check-in:
Expectations, Feedback and Development and provide
suggestions for how to have an eective discussion. ey are not intended to be a script, but to provide
guidelines to prepare employees and people managers before, during and aer the Check-in
conversation.
Best practices for Check-in
e purpose of Check-in is to make sure employees' expectations are clear, share feedback, and discuss
development needs to enhance their performance. e ow of Check-in follows three core steps:
1. Expectations: First, agree what is expected of employees for the year in terms of deliverables,
behavior and contributions.
2. Feedback: Next, provide frequent, two-way feedback to see how employees are progressing
against expectations and let managers know if they could be doing something dierently to beer
support the employee.
3. Development: en, when employees know how they are performing, they can plan actionable
goals in terms of learning, career and experience.
When should Check-ins happen?
Managers should set up a regular cadence of Check-ins for all employees that ts the needs of their team,
but the following guidelines are recommended:
Check-ins should be scheduled at least once a quarter and typically, are 60-90 minutes long.
Expectations should be set in a Check-in at the beginning of Q1 to clarify objectives for the
year ahead.
Feedback can be provided throughout the year, not only in Check-ins.
Development-focused Check-ins are driven by the employee and should be scheduled when they
feel appropriate. Typically, development conversations may happen once or twice per year.
Expectations Discussion Guide
For People Managers
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright © 2010-2015 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Explain how the team fits into the business unit and the broader business.
Confirm the overarching goals for Adobe this year.
Be transparent and explain what is expected of you as a manager of this team. Explain your big bets
for the next year.
Check that the goals the employee has drafted are SMART and complete them together:
"What will success look like for this goal?”
How will these goals stretch you?
What specific outcomes will these produce?
Is this timeframe realistic?
How do these goals align with the business/team goals?"
When and how shall we Check-in to review progress?”
Explain that expectations may need to evolve if the broader business goals change.
Clarify that you will hold your employee accountable to these expectations, so it’s important for
them to let you know if they need to revisit them.
Ensure the employee has specific actions tied to the expectations. Not just what will be achieved,
but HOW.
What obstacles could get in the way of these goals?
How will you plan to overcome these? How can I help?
EXPECTATIONS: Discussion Guide for People Managers
Guidelines:
Take time to do this well: Clear expectations are key to an effective relationship with your team.
As a manager, you will drive the expectation setting process.
Check you have clarity of your own expectations before having this conversation.
Remember: Expectations must be tangible and measurable, not just aspirational.
Follow-Through:
Employee completes expectations worksheet.
Evaluate and refresh throughout the year: Set expectations at the beginning of the fiscal year and review every month or quarter.
Set up recurring calendar invites for Check-in. Avoid cancelling or rescheduling these.
Regularly update all employees with business context/changes/risks.
Use expectations to monitor employee’s progress and achievements throughout the year.
1. Context
2. SMART
4. Review
3. Obstacles
Expectations Worksheet
What are expectations?
Setting expectations is the first of three steps in Adobe’s Check-in process: You and your manager agree upon
key deliverables, behaviors and results for the fiscal year.
Employees are required to set goals based on these expectations. Goals define the specific steps employees
will take to meet the expectations.
Employees and managers should review expectations regularly to ensure they remain relevant as business
priorities and circumstances change.
Employee & manager responsibilities
The manager is responsible for ensuring that employees receive clear expectations that are aligned with
key business needs and priorities.
The employee is responsible for drafting appropriate goals that align to each expectation and to review
these regularly with his/her manager.
Both the manager and employee provide constructive feedback on what’s working and what could
improve.
Getting started:
1. Managers discuss and set clear expectations with their employees
2. Employees draft SMART goals to fulfill business expectations
3. Employees review and refine goals with their manager
4. Managers and employees ask for and give frequent feedback on performance against expectations
5. Managers and employees revisit and revise your expectations in Check-Ins throughout the year
Instructions
Identify the specific goals associated with each of your expectations. Describe the goal, success and measureable results, and the associated
due dates or milestones. If you require additional pages, please print or save multiple versions of this document.
EXPECTATION:
GOAL 1:
DEFINE SUCCESS:
DUE DATES:
GOAL 2:
GOAL 3:
EXPECTATION:
GOAL 1:
DEFINE SUCCESS:
DUE DATES:
GOAL 2:
GOAL 3:
EXPECTATION:
GOAL 1:
DEFINE SUCCESS:
DUE DATES:
GOAL 2:
GOAL 3:
Adobe confidentialnot for external distribution
SMART is an acronym that can help you and your manager identify the associated goals and success criteria for each of your
manager’s expectation.
SPECIFIC:
Who, what, where, when, and why of the achievement
MEASURABLE:
Clear measures of success, key metrics and milestones
ATTAINABLE:
Achievable, and also provides a stretch opportunity to develop and grow
RELEVANT:
Results focused, aligned to Org/BU priorities, and produces tangible results
TIME-BOUND:
A due date gives focus and sense of urgency to the work
This
work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright © 2010-2015 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Role Modeling Check-in
Leading@Adobe
Directions for using
this guide:
ese discussion guides are intended
to help provide a format and talking
points for employees and people
managers during Check-ins. e guides are
organized by the three steps of Check-in:
Expectations, Feedback and Development and provide
suggestions for how to have an eective discussion. ey are not intended to be a script, but to provide
guidelines to prepare employees and people managers before, during and aer the Check-in
conversation.
Best practices for Check-in
e purpose of Check-in is to make sure employees' expectations are clear, share feedback, and discuss
development needs to enhance their performance. e ow of Check-in follows three core steps:
1. Expectations: First, agree what is expected of employees for the year in terms of deliverables,
behavior and contributions.
2. Feedback: Next, provide frequent, two-way feedback to see how employees are progressing
against expectations and let managers know if they could be doing something dierently to beer
support the employee.
3. Development: en, when employees know how they are performing, they can plan actionable
goals in terms of learning, career and experience.
When should Check-ins happen?
Managers should set up a regular cadence of Check-ins for all employees that ts the needs of their team,
but the following guidelines are recommended:
Check-ins should be scheduled at least once a quarter and typically, are 60-90 minutes long
Expectations should be set in a Check-in at the beginning of Q1 to clarify objectives for the
year ahead.
Feedback can be provided throughout the year, not only in Check-ins.
Development-focused Check-ins are driven by the employee and should be scheduled when they
feel appropriate. Typically, development conversations may happen once or twice per year.
Feedback Discussion Guide
For Employees
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright © 2010-2015 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All rights reserved.
FEEDBACK: Discussion Guide for Employees
What do I do well that makes me effective? Why is that impactful?
Are there any areas of performance concern that I need to be aware of?” Ask for specific examples.
When providing feedback, state the specific facts that you know: “I have observed that you do/say
__________and it impacts me in this way ___________.
Pause and take time to respond to the feedback.
Ask for suggestions:
What should I stop, start, continue to do?”
What is one thing, looking forward, I could change or do more of that would make me more
effective?
Collaboratively agree on what needs to continue or change:
What will you do differently in the future?
What help/support would you like from your manager or others to help you stay on track?
Say thank you for the feedback.
When receiving feedback, consider the impact of your behavior on the situation/team. Do you need
to take further action to change that impact?
When providing feedback, describe the impact you observed on other people, both positive and
negative.
Guidelines:
As an employee, you will be part of a two-way feedback conversation.
Provide timely, specific, balanced feedback.
Don’t give feedback when you are angry.
Ask lots of questions to ensure you are clear about the feedback you’re receiving.
Remember: Constructive, critical feedback is often the most helpful to people. Don’t avoid the tough conversations and be open
to hearing difficult feedback.
Follow-Through:
Put agreed-upon changes into action.
Before your next Check-in, consider what feedback you would like to provide.
Regularly ask for business context, changes, and risks.
Regularly ask for informal feedback, not only in your Check-in conversations.
1. Specifics
2. Ask
4. Do
3. Impact
Role Modeling Check-in
Leading@Adobe
Directions for using
this guide:
ese discussion guides are intended
to help provide a format and talking
points for employees and people
managers during Check-ins. e guides are
organized by the three steps of Check-in:
Expectations, Feedback and Development and provide
suggestions for how to have an eective discussion. ey are not intended to be a script, but to provide
guidelines to prepare employees and people managers before, during and aer the Check-in
conversation.
Best practices for Check-in
e purpose of Check-in is to make sure employees' expectations are clear, share feedback, and discuss
development needs to enhance their performance. e ow of Check-in follows three core steps:
1. Expectations: First, agree what is expected of employees for the year in terms of deliverables,
behavior and contributions.
2. Feedback: Next, provide frequent, two-way feedback to see how employees are progressing
against expectations and let managers know if they could be doing something dierently to beer
support the employee.
3. Development: en, when employees know how they are performing, they can plan actionable
goals in terms of learning, career and experience.
When should Check-ins happen?
Managers should set up a regular cadence of Check-ins for all employees that ts the needs of their team,
but the following guidelines are recommended:
Check-ins should be scheduled at least once a quarter and typically, are 60-90 minutes long
Expectations should be set in a Check-in at the beginning of Q1 to clarify objectives for the
year ahead.
Feedback can be provided throughout the year, not only in Check-ins.
Development-focused Check-ins are driven by the employee and should be scheduled when they
feel appropriate. Typically, development conversations may happen once or twice per year.
Feedback Discussion Guide
For People Managers
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright © 2010-2015 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Provide specific feedback based on your observations:
X is something you do very effectively."
“I really appreciate your contributions to (project/team/BU) by doing X.”
“Looking forward, if you could change or do more of X it would make you more effective."
PAUSE and ask for the other person’s reaction.
Ask open-ended questions to understand their perspective:
“If you could do it again, what would you do differently?
How did you feel following that situation?
State or collaboratively agree on what needs to continue or change:
“Can I make a suggestion?...
What help/support would you like from me to help you stay on track?
What feedback do you have for me?” – remember to say thank you for feedback received.
When receiving feedback, consider the impact of your behavior on the situation/team. Do you need
to take further action to change that impact?
When providing feedback, describe the impact you observed on other people, both positive and
negative.
Guidelines:
As a manager, you will be part of a two-way feedback conversation.
Provide timely, specific, balanced feedback.
Show genuine appreciation for your team members and the value they bring to the team.
Motivated employees want to know how they’re doing, tell them!
Don’t give feedback when you are angry.
Remember: Constructive, critical feedback is often the most helpful to people. Don’t avoid the tough conversations and be open
to hearing difficult feedback.
Follow-Through:
Put agreed-upon changes into action.
Regularly provide informal feedback to team members – after meetings, presentations, etc.
Appreciate your team often and in a way that is meaningful for each of them.
Remind your team that you are open to hearing their feedback.
1. Specifics
2. Ask
4. Do
3. Impact
FEEDBACK: Discussion Guide for People Managers
Role Modeling Check-in
Leading@Adobe
Directions for using
this guide:
ese discussion guides are intended
to help provide a format and talking
points for employees and people
managers during Check-ins. e guides are
organized by the three steps of Check-in:
Expectations, Feedback and Development and provide
suggestions for how to have an eective discussion. ey are not intended to be a script, but to provide
guidelines to prepare employees and people managers before, during and aer the Check-in
conversation.
Best practices for Check-in
e purpose of Check-in is to make sure employees' expectations are clear, share feedback, and discuss
development needs to enhance their performance. e ow of Check-in follows three core steps:
1. Expectations: First, agree what is expected of employees for the year in terms of deliverables,
behavior and contributions.
2. Feedback: Next, provide frequent, two-way feedback to see how employees are progressing
against expectations and let managers know if they could be doing something dierently to beer
support the employee.
3. Development: en, when employees know how they are performing, they can plan actionable
goals in terms of learning, career and experience.
When should Check-ins happen?
Managers should set up a regular cadence of Check-ins for all employees that ts the needs of their team,
but the following guidelines are recommended:
Check-ins should be scheduled at least once a quarter and typically, are 60-90 minutes long.
Expectations should be set in a Check-in at the beginning of Q1 to clarify objectives for the
year ahead.
Feedback can be provided throughout the year, not only in Check-ins.
Development-focused Check-ins are driven by the employee and should be scheduled when they
feel appropriate. Typically, development conversations may happen once or twice per year.
Development Discussion Guide
For Employees
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright © 2010-2015 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All rights reserved.
Explain what you find most and least satisfying about your current role and why.
Discuss other things you really enjoy doing and why.
Explain what you believe your strengths and development areas are.
“Does this align with your perspective? Is there something I’m missing?”
“I’ve identified some experiences, coaching or learning to help me develop. What do you think
is missing?”
Discuss the potential results/business impact of these activities.
“How did you develop your own career?
Discuss specific actions you can take to achieve your goal(s).
Agree upon a realistic timeframe and how to track progress against actions.
Consider potential obstacles and how you will overcome them.
Explain your short-term (up to 12 months) and long-term (2-5 years) career aspirations.
What do you think could be a logical career step for me at Adobe?
“How well do you think my aspirations link to Adobe’s goals?
DEVELOPMENT: Discussion Guide for Employees
Guidelines:
Expectations and Feedback Check-ins must happen before a development conversation.
Reflect on interests and aspirations (use Individual Development Plan).
Schedule meeting with your manager. You will likely have a series of meetings, not just one.
Come to the meeting with some clear ideas to discuss.
Remember this is a journey: don’t move straight to action.
Follow-Through:
Employee completes Individual Development Plan (IDP).
Schedule a follow-up meeting with manager to review progress.
Ideally, you should review development plans every 3-6 months as part of Check-in.
Explore online resources and internal opportunities (roles, transfers, projects, etc.).
Before your next development Check-in with your manager, reflect on the progress you've made.
1. Current
State
2. Strengths
4. Plan
5. Action
3. Aspirations
Role Modeling Check-in
Leading@Adobe
Directions for using
this guide:
ese discussion guides are intended
to help provide a format and talking
points for employees and people
managers during Check-ins. e guides are
organized by the three steps of Check-in:
Expectations, Feedback and Development and provide
suggestions for how to have an eective discussion. ey are not intended to be a script, but to provide
guidelines to prepare employees and people managers before, during and aer the Check-in
conversation.
Best practices for Check-in
e purpose of Check-in is to make sure employees' expectations are clear, share feedback, and discuss
development needs to enhance their performance. e ow of Check-in follows three core steps:
1. Expectations: First, agree what is expected of employees for the year in terms of deliverables,
behavior and contributions.
2. Feedback: Next, provide frequent, two-way feedback to see how employees are progressing
against expectations and let managers know if they could be doing something dierently to beer
support the employee.
3. Development: en, when employees know how they are performing, they can plan actionable
goals in terms of learning, career and experience.
When should Check-ins happen?
Managers should set up a regular cadence of Check-ins for all employees that ts the needs of their team,
but the following guidelines are recommended:
Check-ins should be scheduled at least once a quarter and typically, are 60-90 minutes long.
Expectations should be set in a Check-in at the beginning of Q1 to clarify objectives for the
year ahead.
Feedback can be provided throughout the year, not only in Check-ins.
Development-focused Check-ins are driven by the employee and should be scheduled when they
feel appropriate. Typically, development conversations may happen once or twice per year.
Development Discussion Guide
For People Managers
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright © 2010-2015 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All rights reserved.
DEVELOPMENT: Discussion Guide for People Managers
What parts of your current job do you find most satisfying and why?
What parts are less satisfying and why?
What are your key skills and strengths?”
What is a critical development area for you?”
What business trends or skills do you need to learn more about to remain relevant?”
What types of experiences, coaching, and/or learning do you need to fulfil your aspirations?”
What will be the potential results/business impact of these activities?”
As your manager, how can I help?
What specific actions can you take to achieve your goal(s)?”
What obstacles, if any, may get in the way?”
“How would you like us to monitor your progress against these goals?”
What are your short and long-term career goals?
“Let’s look at how your aspirations link to Adobe’s goals.”
“Do you have a specific career move that you want to make?
(Specialist to expert, buddy to boss, international moves, etc.)
Guidelines:
Expectations and Feedback Check-ins must happen before a development conversation.
Encourage don’t direct.
Support employees on their development journey.
Provide business context.
Listen 70%/Talk 30%.
Provide clarity, but don’t feel like you have to have all the answers.
Remember this is a journey: don’t move straight to action.
Follow-Through:
Employee completes the Individual Development Plan (IDP).
Guide employee to online/on-demand resources.
Explore internal opportunities (roles, transfers, projects).
Confirm date for next development Check-in to review progress.
Ideally, you should review development plans every 3-6 months as part of Check-in.
1. Current
State
2. Strengths
4. Plan
5. Action
3. Aspirations
Objective:
Create a personal development plan that aligns your strengths, career aspirations and business needs.
Reect on the questions below prior to your development discussion with your manager.
Individual Development Plan
(IDP)
WHAT PARTS OF YOUR JOB DO YOU FIND MOST SATISFYING?
Most Satisfying? Why?
WHAT ARE YOUR KEY SKILLS OR STRENGTHS? WHAT SKILLS OR STRENGTHS DO YOU WANT
TO DEVELOP?
WHAT ARE YOUR SHORT AND LONG-TERM CAREER GOALS?
This includes experiences you would like, not just promotions (e.g., running an event, speaking at a conference, or managing a team)
Short Term (6-12 months): Long Term (2 to 5 years):
WHAT TYPE OF ASSIGNMENTS, EXPERIENCES, COACHING AND/OR LEARNING DO YOU NEED TO MEET YOUR GOALS?
How can your manager help?
Action Plan: Complete during or aer development discussion with manager
DEVELOPMENT
OPPORTUNITY
SPECIFIC ACTIONS YOU WILL TAKE BUSINESS IMPACT/RESULTS COMPLETION
DATE
Next Steps:
Best practices indicate that you should review development plans every 3-6 months as part of Check-In.
Next Development Plan Review Date:
This work is licens
ed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright © 2010-2015 Adobe Systems Incorporated. All rights reserved.